Here's the WSJ Review:
Yet another comic exercise in applied identity politics is playing one block east of “Straight White Men”: “Head Over Heels” is a jukebox musical whose score consists of songs recorded by the Go-Go’s, an all-female new-wave power-pop group that had a brief vogue in the ’80s. Very freely adapted by Jeff Whitty from “The Arcadia,” Philip Sidney’s 16th-century pastoral romance about mistaken gender identity, it’s been extensively reworked by James Magruder since its original 2015 Oregon Shakespeare Festival run, to no more than modest effect. The book is still a sophomoric mess, and the 17 songs, which are mostly either fast or rather less so, are lively but unvaried.
Michael Mayer (“Spring Awakening&rdquo
has done what he can to put a directorial shine on “Head Over Heels.” Spencer Liff’s choreography is excitingly volatile and the sets and costumes are expensively fancy, while the five-piece pit band is as hot as a runaway atomic pile. Bonnie Milligan, a delightful performer with pipes to die for who previously appeared in the 2015 production, nails best-in-show honors as the horrifically vain Princess Pamela, who searches in vain for a suitable swain, then belatedly figures out that she’s a lesbian (GASP!). Everyone else in the cast takes care of business, and if you really, really like the Go-Go’s, you might possibly find the results tolerable. I doubt there are still enough Go-Go’s fans out there to make “Head Over Heels” a hit, but stranger things have happened on Broadway.