The biggest problem I have with the idea of this show is the extremely limited dynamic range of the Go-Gos catalog of music, especially their hits. You could set a metronome to We Got the Beat, Vacation, Mad About You and Head Over Heels alone and barely register the change from one tune to the next, which is why, love their songs as much as I do, I can only take them in small doses. Even in the 80s, I could rarely sit through an entire album in one sitting. The score would need MASSIVE amounts of artistic license in the arrangements and orchestrations to create some interesting theatrical variations and based on what I've heard, it's not happening nearly enough.
Arcadia itself is a fun romp and the idea to adapt it for a musical isn't a bad one. Not even with a (mostly) Go-Gos jukebox score. Mimicking the era smacks of an attempt to ride the coattails of Something Rotten, but it doesn't really work when you layer on contrived faux Tudorian-era language on top of a story 99.9% of audiences aren't familiar with. If you're not going to attempt much change in the arrangements of the songs, then set it in the 80s and use that vernacular. Otherwise, make it current-day and focus on the arrangements and writing. This thing was just muddied with too many conceptual ideas and lack of artistic objectivity. I don't know how anyone can listen to that pretend stylized dialogue and find it cute (much less funny) for that long. It reminds me of a 7 year-old that accidentally says something the adults laugh at, so they just repeat it, thinking they'll surely get the same reaction every single time, until they are either yelled at or just ignored. This thing reminds me of his attempt to reinvent On a Clear Day. An interesting idea that fails in execution so spectacularly, you have to wonder how he never saw its glaring flaws.
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian
Updated On: 8/1/18 at 04:13 PM