I enjoyed seeing it. I saw it a few times for a number of reasons and enjoyed it each time. It's not the best musical ever, its somewhat uneven. But the lead cast was good (and I too went back to see Anthony Warlow) and some of those boys are spectacular. I would have liked have seen Jeremy Jordan in the lead but I don't fault Matthew for not being him. That doesn't seem fair. I enjoyed what he did well enough.
And there are some parts of the show I looked forward to each time I saw it..and again, if someone new was in the show I wanted to see, I would probably go again. I personally look forward to the moment when James imagines the children are flying..love that part. Each time I went, the audience as a whole LOVED it.