There was no review thread for this play because no one bothered to start one. I guess people were still too busy debating Slave Play and the casting for Company to even notice this had opened. LOL. There is a brief previews thread that can be searched for.
The critics' reviews overall were mixed to positive with a few negatives. While critics fairly consistently lauded most, if not all of the performances and unanimously praised the two leads, some critics were intrigued by the premise of the play and really enjoyed the twists and turns and the lack of clarity of what was actually happening, while other critics including Jesse Green at the Times just felt the audience was being played with and overly manipulated being pushed in one direction and then being yanked in another, resented that and as a result downgraded their view of the play.
I really enjoyed it. It drew me in and of course Pryce and Atkins were masterful. I wondered while watching it if I was the only one without clarity as to what was actually going on and how to interpret the arrivals, departures and interactions of certain characters. Glad to know I wasn't. We're all so used to plays, movies and especially T.V. shows where everything is neatly wrapped up and every plot point is resolved in the last scene, a show like this is an outlier but of the 11 shows I saw on my recent trip, it's one of the 2 or 3 I was still thinking about days after I saw it and that's not a bad thing. A definite go see it from me if for no other reason than to watch two master actors at the top of their game and there are plenty of other reasons.