This is certainly an odd one for lack of a better word... This is a top notch production. The cast is great. The set and costumes are quite impressive and grand. The dancing is awesome. All this being said, though, this production feels flat.
Kelli O’Hara and Will Chase are at the top of their games vocally and play well off of each other. However, neither of them are ever over the top. They seem to be playing their characters with restraint, which doesn’t really work for this show.
The set and costumes are very well done and quite impressive. No expenses were spared here. The transitions between the various locations inside the theatre where the show is set are seamless. Overall, it’s a cohesive and graceful design.
Roundabout (usually) knocks their musical revivals out of the park. I found Anything Goes and She Loves Me to be prestigious and thrilling. Kiss Me, Kate reminded me a lot of their production On the Twentieth Century a couple seasons ago. Great cast, a beautiful set, but it just felt like a production you would see at Paper Mill Playhouse or any other top notch regional theatre.
I really wanted to love this, but it just didn’t thrill me in any way. It’s a perfectly passable production for sure, and it’s not bad by any means, but it’s also just not particularly exciting. I was much more entertained with the Great Performances version with Rachel York and Brent Barrett that I watched than I was with this production.
"There’s nothing quite like the power and the passion of Broadway music. "