The OP's anger also is strange. The OP says the choice was between Pirates and La Cage and the choice was dictated by whether there were sopranos. So, presumably, the choice had nothing to do with "it gets better" or the message of La Cage. If the anger is simply at being told "no" - then the OP had better get used to being told "no". As has been suggested, there are plenty of other shows which don't rely on sopranos.
In any event, the Samuel French site says the title is restricted - and there is a professional production in Petaluma in October which is right next to Marin - so a licence may never have issued or maybe the school learned it wouldn't issue. There are 18 productions listed, and none are for a high school. The site says it is for "College Theatre / Student, Community Theatre, Professional Theatre". So maybe it is not licensed to high schools. Other musicals indicate "High School" as an audience.
And you never know - my daughter's drama teacher wanted to do Urinetown (a show Marin apparently has performed). The head of the fine arts department said "no" with the stated reason of "inappropriate" (the High Schools has students as young as 12)and "not large enough orchestra". We're not sure he listened to the music or read the script - and in his multi-decade tenure, he's not approved a musical more recent than Cabaret. So, they ended up performing Forum and my daughter was cast as Pseudolus. The production was 100 times more "inappropriate" for High School than Urinetown could ever have been.
Samuel French Listing
Updated On: 8/1/13 at 07:33 PM