Jarethan said: "jkstheatrescene said: "GRIND
SMILE
TRIUMPH OF LOVE"
Did you actually see them? The great thing about the human experience is how differently we can react to the same performances; that said, Grind and Smile would definitely fall in the list of the 10 worst musicalsI have ever seen in 50 plusyears of attending the theater, along with gems like Dr. Jazz, Copperfield, Jimmy, Come Summer, BringBack Birdie, Cats, Spiderman, and maybe Rocky and Triumph of Love, which I liked a little more than yourfirst two, but still really didn't like.
My personal list would include:
-- Darling of the Day
-- Drat! The Cat!
-- Cyrano (Christopher Plummer version)
-- Over Here (ran for over 300 performances, but seems pretty forgotten
-- King of Hearts
-- The Grand Tour (even though it is Jerry Herman, it still doesn't get mentioned like Mack and Mabel and it was much more entertaining than that.
-- Baby
-- I Love My Wife (probably very dated, but the score was terrific fun and it would work today if set clearly in its time)
ANDIS IT TOO EARLY MENTION
-- Bandstand
"
Yes, I actually saw all three. And enjoyed them all for very different reasons. (For the record, Smile, in its pre-Broadway try-out in Baltimore, was MUCH MUCH MUCH better than what ended up on Broadway. It was sharp and dark. Not so much at the Lunt-Fontanne.)