Annette170-What I mean is that Wildhorn shows have never been been a huge hit. None of his shows have really had long runs, one only needs to look at his show history. J an H one can argue was a "hit" as it ran almost four years, but it also was one that suffered from many different rewrites and restructuring and has about 3 versions of it. Pimpernel has twice that many rewrite versions and ran just over two years. Wildhorn is considered a bit of a hack in the MT world likely due to his unspecific way of writing music and while I can see why, I think his stuff is under appreciated. One can't deny his songs are anthemic, singers love singing them regardless. I'm no exception. Sadly just having his name attached to a project due to his history seems to be a bit of a curse for him. I've always hoped he'd have a "Schwartz" moment and FINALLY have a show that's a gargantuan hit but sadly no luck as of yet...I still hope, even some said back during Bonnie and Clyde that they were hoping that would be his redemption, so to speak, but sadly we all know what happened there. I still like his work well enough anyway.
I also agree Pimpernel can exists without Sills. It's may be his most famous role he put such a stamp on, but I doubt even he'd want to be a part of it's revival, he's past the age for that role anyhow.
Updated On: 2/20/19 at 11:07 AM