Saw this last night and I have very similar opinions to some others echoed here. I had seen the show in the tent in midtown and didn't actually love it. Having seen this new interpretation, I feel entirely differently. The bigger scale production has drastically changed the show, much to my delight, for the better.
The story is without a doubt very insubstantial. It's a trite tale of unrequited love/societal limitations placed upon women. This show, however, is not about the story. I was enraptured the entire time (and it's on the longer side, very close to full three hours). The music is unlike anything that's ever been on Broadway before and that isn't to say anything about the truly thrilling scenic design, choreography, costuming, lighting design and utilization of the space. It's anachronistic and modern and inventive.
It is, of course, very similar to Hadestown and someone earlier in this thread referenced the NY Magazine review of that show, in which Jesse Green described it as an "illustrated pop concert." That idea sort of applies here as well. If you want to see a musical with a story that will touch you, this is not that show. If you want to have a theatrical Experience that will put you outside of yourself and allow you to feel something new in a Broadway house, this one is for you. I, frankly, cannot wait to see it again.
Updated On: 10/23/16 at 12:39 PM