Observations from the first preview in Toronto:
Priscilla Queen of the Desert is a musical-comedy romp in the Mamma Mia vein--only a thousand times gayer. And just as Mamma Mia audiences leap to their feet to sing the reprise of "Dancing Queen" at the end of the show, the opening night preview audience at Priscilla lept to their feet to sing the reprise of "I Will Survive." It's that kind of show.
Based on the 1994 film, Priscilla brings the fabulous styles (the flip-flp dress, the lizard costume) and piercing Aussie accents to the stage. The music runs the gamut from rousing gay pride parade-type standards ("It's Raining Men," "Girls Just Wanna Have Fun", "Go West") to a maudlin rendition of "True Colors." But what the stage version lacks is the heart that makes the film both touching and funny. While it IS entertaining, there's not a lot of depth.
Will Swenson seems slightly miscast as the main character of Tick, who leads his confreres across the desert in a bus ostensibly to perform a drag show, but in reality to be reunited with his young son (from a--gasp!--straight marriage). Alas, I couldn't quite buy Swenson as his flamboyant drag queen alter ego Mitzi, nor did I find his manly Tick all that emotionally compelling. Vocally, he was not that strong, either. What he, and the character need, is more drama--both the emotional and the queenly kind.
Tony Sheldon (Bernadette) comes across as an old pro, and indeed he's a veteran of both the Australian and West End productions of Priscilla. I have no problems with his performance, though I was neither surpised nor truly moved by it, either.
Adam/Felicia is the perfect role for Nick Adams--truly, all his, um, assets are on full display. Imbuing Adam/Felicia with vanity and the imperviousness of youth, he just needs to sharpen the character's humor, mischieviousness, and grating/annoying quality. Clearly a showy role, Swenson's Tick (who should be the main characer) seems dim in comparison. Though not distinctive, Nick's voice was the strongest of the leads. And he's a solid dancer--and clearly very flexible.
The audience (which had more gay men than Saturday night at Woody's, not to mention some real live drag queens--one of whom kindly removed her wig so as not to impede the view of the people behind her--what courtesy!) ate up the show. They laughed at the opening strains of "I Say A Little Prayer" and clearly knew the movie well--laughing at first appearance of Cynthia (J. Elaine Marcos), Bob's (C. David Johnson) crazy Asian mail-order bride. Beware the ping pong balls! Some of the jokes come straight out of the movie; others are new. I don't think that people who haven't seen the movie will be at a disadvantage--and might even benefit by not knowing the punch lines in advance.
The (female, singing) divas (who are frequently seen hanging on a wire above the stage) were fine, as was the orchestra/band, and the ensemble was very good--notably the petite, plus-sized Keala Settle, who played a variety of funny roles and the fierce Nathan Lee Graham as Miss Understanding.
The costumes were truly specacular. Particularly fantabulous was Trumpet's funeral, which begins with a tableaux of guests (recalling the Ascot scene in My Fair Lady) dressed in outrageous Alexander McQueen-meets-Lady Gaga-type funeral finery. They then proceed to sing "Don't Leave Me This Way," one of many disco hits in the show, including "Hot Stuff", "MacArthur Park," "Shake Your Grove Thing" and "Boogie Wonderland." For the North American adaptation, Kylie Minogue songs were replaced with Madonna songs, such as "Material Girl," "Holiday," and "Like A Prayer."
Despite the complexity of the show, it doesn't appear any major changes are required, only a sharpening of the lead performances and fixing of some timing issues (the actors need to pause after some of the bigger jokes as the dialog was being drowned out by laughter). While curmudgeons will shudder, those that like to wave rainbow flags on Pride Day (or wear feather boas to the theatre--as some did) will have a blast. Opening night is October 26th.
Note: It was just announced that Bette Midler is joining the producing team of Priscilla. Supposedly she will be attending previews and offering notes, among other things.
http://www.cbc.ca/arts/theatre/story/2010/10/13/midler-priscilla-toronto.html
Coach Bob knew it all along: you've got to get obsessed and stay obsessed. You have to keep passing the open windows. (John Irving, The Hotel New Hampshire)