Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they should have WON that season.
Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they should have WON that season.
#0Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they should have WON that season.
Posted: 8/16/06 at 9:17pm
What performances were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they should have WON that given season?
(Know your season and look at the nominees in the Tony Awards Database:)
https://www.broadwayworld.com/tonyawards.cfm
My thoughts on a performance denied a nomination AND a win:
2002 - Best Leading Actor in a Musical
The nominees were (winner in bold):
John Lithgow Sweet Smell of Success
Gavin Creel Thoroughly Modern Millie
John McMartin Into the Woods
Patrick Wilson Oklahoma!
John Cullum Urinetown: The Musical
HUNTER FOSTER was denied a nomination for his brilliant comedic tour de force in the groundbreaking, critically welcomed new musical, Urinetown. Foster's performance was the heart of Urinetown and he not only should have taken John Cullum's nomination (where did THAT come from?) but Mr. Foster should have WON the Tony Award for his performance as Bobby Strong in Urinetown. And had he won, his career would be in a completely different place than it is now.
-Kad
"I have also met him in person, and I find him to be quite funny actually. Arrogant and often misinformed, but still funny."
-bjh2114 (on Michael Riedel)
JoMarch
Featured Actor Joined: 9/22/04
#1re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they should have WON that season.
Posted: 8/16/06 at 9:23pmMichael Hayden in Carousel. None of the other 1994 Best Actor in a Musical nominees gave performances that affected me in the way that Michael's heartbreaking portrayal did.
#2re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they should have WON that season.
Posted: 8/16/06 at 9:23pm
2004 - Best Featured Actress in a Musical
Beth Fowler, The Boy From Oz
Isabel Keating, The Boy From Oz
*Anika Noni Rose, Caroline, or Change
Jennifer Westfeldt, Wonderful Town
Karen Ziemba, Never Gonna Dance
Carole Shelly (Wicked) and Randy Graff (Fiddler on the Roof) were my two favorites that year and neither one was nominated. I think either one of them could have won if they were nominated.
#3re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they should have WON that season.
Posted: 8/16/06 at 9:25pmMaria Friedman in "The Woman in White." Easily my favorite performance of the season.
To Kill A Mockingbird
mijofly19
Broadway Star Joined: 6/14/05
#4re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 9:26pm
2005-Best Featured Actor in a Musical
Winner: Dan Fogler
Should have been nominated & won: Jesse Tyler Ferguson
Dan was great, but Jesse was the standout of that show.
Also this year, Cherry Jones could have been Leading Actress in a Play, and would have won.
Updated On: 8/16/06 at 09:26 PM
#5re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 9:29pmWow. I did not even realize Hunter Foster was not nominated. I must have forgotten. But he DEFINATELY deserved to at least be nominated. He was truly outstanding in the role.
mijofly19
Broadway Star Joined: 6/14/05
#6re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 9:29pmMy mistake, I meant play. I'll change it.
#7re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 9:33pm
One of the worlds greatest injustices was the loss of Tonya Pinkin for Caroline, or Change.
Yes, I know she was nominated so technically doesn't belong on this thread but, come on. WHAT THE HELL WAS UP WITH THAT!!!??
whatyouown223
Broadway Legend Joined: 1/4/05
#8re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 9:34pmPiazza should have won over Spamalot.
#9re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 9:36pmSpelling Bee should have won over Spamalot
MargoChanning
Broadway Legend Joined: 4/5/04
#10re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 9:37pmFunny thing, Cherry Jones was in Imaginary Friends, a play with music by Nora Ephron (music by Marvin Hamlisch, lyrics by Craig Carnelia and choreography by Jerry Mitchell), a few seasons ago with Swoosie Kurtz in which she sang and danced. Pretty well, actually. No Tony nomination for that one either.
jonartdesigns
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/15/04
#11re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 9:37pm
anne harada for avenue q
maybe raul esparza for rocky horror
BwayBaby18
Broadway Legend Joined: 2/19/05
#12re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 9:47pm
1996 Actress (Featured Role--Musical)
Winner - Ann Duquesnay (Bring in 'da Noise)
Nominees: Joohee Choi (The King and I)
Veanne Cox (Company)
Idina Menzel (Rent)
Where was Rachel York's nomination and win?
#13re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 9:51pm
2004 - Best Featured Actress in a Musical
Beth Fowler, The Boy From Oz
Isabel Keating, The Boy From Oz
*Anika Noni Rose, Caroline, or Change
Jennifer Westfeldt, Wonderful Town
Karen Ziemba, Never Gonna Dance
Carole Shelly (Wicked) and Randy Graff (Fiddler on the Roof) were my two favorites that year and neither one was nominated. I think either one of them could have won if they were nominated.
I would have easily taken away Beth Fowler's nomination (who was just dandy in The Boy From Oz but) I would give that nomination to Stephanie J. Block instead, who gave a hardcore performance as Liza Minelli in The Boy From Oz and handed her the Tony easily.
I would also remove Karen Ziemba's pity nomination and give it (and the Tony) to Natalie Venetia Belcon, who I thought gave the most brilliant performance in AVENUE Q. She was the complete standout for me -- comically, singing-wise, and she had the character of Gary Coleman down to a T. Brilliant, completely underrated performance!
-Kad
"I have also met him in person, and I find him to be quite funny actually. Arrogant and often misinformed, but still funny."
-bjh2114 (on Michael Riedel)
ZONEACE
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/10/05
#14re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 9:53pmthats all well and good, but Anika was the clear winner of that award. Like, no matter who you put her up against, she still was the best.
#15re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 10:01pm
1995 - Best Featured Actress in a Musical
The nominees were (winner in bold):
Gretha Boston Show Boat
Brenda Braxton Smokey Joe's Cafe
B.J. Crosby Smokey Joe's Cafe
DeLee Lively Smokey Joe's Cafe
I saw Smokey Joe's and Show Boat but I still would have handed that Tony to LILLIAS WHITE for her performance that tore up the stage every night as Miss Jones in How To Succeed.... She owned that stage, and for those of you who saw her, and even if you own the Cast Recording, you can easily see that she deserved a Tony win above all of these other performances. I think the reason that all of the Featured performers from H2$ were left out of the nominations was because the focus of this whole production was primarily on Matthew Broderick.
-Kad
"I have also met him in person, and I find him to be quite funny actually. Arrogant and often misinformed, but still funny."
-bjh2114 (on Michael Riedel)
#16re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 10:04pm
Actress (Musical) Winner - Barbara Harris (The Apple Tree)
Nominees: Lotte Lenya (Cabaret)
Mary Martin (I Do! I Do!)
Louise Troy (Walking Happy)
Should have won and been nominated: Jill Hayworth, Cabaret
This is just judging by recordings, but while I do love Barbara Harris, I think it is remarkable that Jill Hayworth did not get nominated for Sally in Cabaret. To this day she remains my favorite Sally. She brought such a chilling sensation to the finale that Liza could never express (or chose not to).
Updated On: 8/16/06 at 10:04 PM
#17re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 10:07pmNathan Lane - Love, Vaalour, Compassion
#18re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 10:11pm
I have one more (for now):
Actor (Featured Role--Musical)
Winner - Michael Cerveris, Assassins
Nominees: John Cariani, Fiddler on the Roof
Raul Esparza, Taboo
Michael McElroy, Big River
Denis O'Hare, Assassins
Should have won and been nominated: Marc Kudisch, Assassins
If I had to pick a winner from the nominees that year I would have picked Denis, but he nor Michael Cerveris surpassed Marc in Assassins. Such a smooth and dark interpretation.
Updated On: 8/16/06 at 10:11 PM
#19re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 10:16pmjewishboy, in that category I would have nominated and HANDED that Tony to TYRONE GIORDANO for BIG RIVER (he was BRILLIANT!) His facial expressions and signing alone were better than any other spoken and sung performance that season.
-Kad
"I have also met him in person, and I find him to be quite funny actually. Arrogant and often misinformed, but still funny."
-bjh2114 (on Michael Riedel)
lovesclassics
Broadway Star Joined: 10/7/05
#20re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 10:32pm
BroadwayBaby18,
I'm with you all the way about Rachel York. The irony is, she is probably better known for NOT getting a Tony for Victor/Victoria than she would be if she had won. Just goes to show - one award does not make or break a career.
lc
wickedrentq
Broadway Legend Joined: 11/6/04
#21re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 10:39pm
Well, there goes my speech. Ditto LC 
i*heart*fame
Broadway Star Joined: 9/15/04
#22re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 10:51pmI believe that if Christian Borle had been nominated in 2005 for Spamalot that he would have won. That said, I don't feel as though any actor impressed me that much last year.
i*heart*fame
Broadway Star Joined: 9/15/04
#23re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 10:51pmI believe that if Christian Borle had been nominated in 2005 for Spamalot that he would have won. That said, I don't feel as though any actor impressed me that much last year.
Benzy92
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/24/03
#24re: Performances that were not only denied a Tony nomination, but they shou
Posted: 8/16/06 at 11:05pmJanine LaManna in Seussical.. maybe not a "win" but she should have def. been nominated..
Videos