At intermission now - this is so phenomenal! Having see the KC version, I can say this is so much better. So many wonderful choices, a few misses but on the whole - wow. Will write more later.
Ok - back. Overall, this was such a thrilling production - so intimate, sat in the front row and felt like I was eavesdropping on a private party. I loved so much of this production - the cast was brilliant - particularly the four leads. I found Mr. Barrett so charming and handsome and yet real - finally a Ben I can see women going crazy over. . . and he sings the score so beautifully. Moniz was brilliant as Sally - what a voice - her Losing My Mind was such a highlight. Petkoff was great as Buddy. For some reason he seemed so period and played it so hurt and such a different interpretation than Burstein who I felt played it with a faint smile. O'Connor was strong but a bit campy for me - it may just be that I am so used to tall, statuesque-type Phyllis that I could not get used to it (shame on me) but I saw her play Velma in Sydney and this was bit too close to that performance for my comfort (especially the dancing in Lucy and Jessie).
A few of the choices that made my night - Hattie taking a long drink of champagne before singing Broadway Baby, mixing Vincent and Vanessa with Rain on the Roof characters, Young Stella actually singing behind her older self in WTM, Carlotta beginning I'm Still Here to Weismann - they way she sang it to him made me think as though they've had some crazy times together.
Some of the misses: they cast the younger selves as VERY SMALL people, the women looked like teenagers and it made for a very awkward "Too Many Mornings." The Loveland sequences were too Fosse- especially Mr. Cello/Me and My Baby for Buddy's Blues, All I Care About for Live/Laugh/Love (didn't he play Billy Flint?) and most of Velma's songs from Chicago. I also did not think Ben's breakdown was strong - still have not seen anything that tops the way Papermill handled this moment. And the men's costumes were 20 rented tuxes - not tailored very well.
I read some of the other reviews and wanted to comment on that, as well. I didn't read the characters acknowledging the ghosts in Who's That Woman - I saw it as, dancing as though you are staring at the mirror was part of the choreography. Same with Too Many Mornings, this is happening in their heads as Sally is still obsessed with Young Ben and Ben is tipsy and thinking about the time he made it with Sally (years ago). This is done very well in the Bway revival.
"Observe how bravely I conceal this dreadful dreadful shame I feel."
Updated On: 10/8/11 at 10:00 PM