Well, we have the East/West Players in L.A. who do all sorts of works with largely Asian casts. If they haven't done Neil Simon by now, I'm sure they'll get to him eventually.
I don't have their mission statement in front of me, but I don't think the casting at East/West is merely arbitrary. It is at least (a) an effort to open the eyes of the audience to alternative casting possibilities; and (b) an attempt to compensate for the relative paucity of Asian-American roles.
I assume we are all joking about doing August Wilson with non-black casts. Wilson set out deliberately to expose a history of African-Americans that had been consciously and unconsciously hidden by American culture as a whole. I might could be convinced that FENCES has been done so many times that the history is now known and productions can move on, but changing the races of the characters rather flies in the face of the play's intent.
Although a black STREETCAR will never be definitive for me (for reasons I've belabored at this point), I'm not just being politically correct when I say I see no harm in trying it. Given the popularity of GONE WITH THE WIND, Williams, Faulkner, O'Connor, Welty and other Southern writers, it's hard to argue the history of white Southerners has been suppressed.
And who knows? It's entirely possible that a black STREETCAR will reveal things about the play we have failed to notice in the past.
I didn't think Ian McKellan's all-Nazi RICHARD III was "definitive", but it was sure as hell interesting.
(It occurred to me later that I somehow managed to equate African-Americans and Nazis. I trust everyone will realize the equation was entirely accidental; my point was just that there are benefits to nontraditional casting and conceptualization.)
Updated On: 1/27/12 at 02:00 PM