Saw this on Wednesday night. Felt that the cast was quite good for the usual Encores rehearsal period and understood the decision to use the radio show concept (and thank you to whoever mentioned that the director deliberately cut back on it as the show went on, I wondered about that).
I felt that Brandown Uranowitz did well and loved Jin Ha (especially after seeing him in M. Butterfly). To me, Raul Esparza was doing the evil alter ego of his Jonas Nightingale from Leap of Faith, and I got a bit tired of watching his twitchy moves. I always enjoy seeing Liz McCArtney, Mary Beth Peil and Chuck Cooper, but I do wish that Liz was not just listed as "ensemble". Funnily, the "New York Sequence" song had come up on my iPod twice on the days before seeing the show, so I kind of knew what to expect.
I liked the attempts at period costumes, but wondered why a bunch of radio performers would be so dressed up and in coats and everything. I also liked the "postcards" during Addison's voyages, but wish they had some how conveyed a sense of time as well as place. I didn't understand why that had Raul singing that song, I think it would have worked better as just an ensemble number commenting on Addison's adventures instead of Wilson. And I agree with a prior post, I don't know why they had so many of the performers smoking, again, if it was supposed to be a radio studio, that was illogical.
All in all, I'd give it a 7 out of 10.