I saw the show for the final time on Saturday and could not have been more thrilled with the closing state of the company.
Having seen every Violet to come through the cast (including Susanne Marley,) I found Phylicia Rashad to be the most powerful by far. What's interesting is that each woman brought a distinctly different quality to the role, which speaks for the brilliance of the creative team's casting choices.
Dunagan was the most "fierce", but she lacked an emotional vulnerability and humanity that made you feel for her amidst her acidity. Parsons was less calculating in her destructiveness, but the lack of fire in her passiveness robbed many of the "big" scenes of the fire that Dunagan nailed in spades (though both performances were equally effective.) Marley was a good amalgamation of the two, but I didn't see a lot of originality in many of her choices (which can obviously be attributed to the fact that her job is to cover the performances of the principal she's understudying.)
Rashad, however, found a balance between all those traits that packed the most stirring punch out of the woman that preceded her. Her Violet was genuinely maternal and seemingly good intentioned (like Parsons,) but still threatening enough to turn on a dime at any given moment and become genuinely menacing (like Dunagan.) As others have said, she also managed to make Violet appear genuinely lucid from her medication while still acting very decisively.
Her final moments following Barbara's departure were absolutely jarring. She wrung things out of that portion particularly that no one ever came close to before. As she walked from room to room and discovered the emptiness in her house and her life, you genuinely felt her personal destruction come to a final, stunning blow. Her "...and then they're gone" closer left me in tears of disbelief, which was the first time that moment possessed that much of an emotional impact for me.
The rest of the cast remained as terrific as they've always been.
I am excited to see the show live on as a staple of American drama for years to come. It's beyond wonderful to see a play provide such resonance for audiences in this day and age!
Tonya Pinkins: Then we had a "Lot's Wife" last June that was my personal favorite. I'm still trying to get them to let me sing it at some performance where we get to sing an excerpt that's gone.
Tony Kushner: You can sing it at my funeral.
Updated On: 6/29/09 at 02:40 PM