Posted: 1/31/20 at 3:54pm
Scarlet Leigh said: "Impossible2 said: "The new line upin the London cast atm isthe best of the lot. Millie is gone now so the weakest link vocally (thoughher acting was great) is out. The new Boleyn is fantastic and the new Parr is phenomenal. The other originals are and were always the strongest."
Okay. Sidebar. THANK YOU for making me feel less crazy. I have always felt crazy because Millie was like the most beloved of the original West End cast but I just personally cringed anytime I heard her sing be it in a megasix or in one of special performance. It always felt like I was missing something that everyone else was seeing or hearing. It was refreshing for me hear the megasix with the new actresses like the US one and the replacement.
"The London Cleves is the best by far. The W.E.L performance was tothe original shorter backing track so it’s faster and in a different key to the live performance with the band at the show, which is why she sounded so off. She also did all her adlibs when there was clearly not enough time to get them all in on the shorter version of the track. So she sounds ahead of/behind the track all the time.Mack is very over the top energetic and is vocally on point, but she’s missingthe cool, dry, tongue in cheeksarcasm, amazing facial expressionsand comic timing that Alexia nails completely. The UK tour Cleves plays it very similar to Mack and is also very goodand there’s nothing wrong with that interpretation. But Alexia underplays it and let’s the audience get the jokes on their own, where as I feel Mack overplays it & makes it about ‘her’ performance instead of playing the character."
Again, it's a to each their own. I personally prefer Mack's over the top interpretation of the character who is living her rich life to the fullest and partying hard while doing it. It's fun and energetic and I just like that a lot. Puts a bit smile on my face. Also I like her vocally better as well."
The last time I saw Millie just before she left she actually sounded really good and had finally sorted out her pitching issues, but damn it took her a very long time to get there. I think she just gets really excited when she's performing and that throws her vocals out. She was more loved for the way she played the character and her excellent comedic timing more than her voice which you kind of accepted because lets face it Lily Allen ain't the greatest singer and that's who the character is based on. I always cringed my way through her song, but she is great in all the comedy scenes and always stole the show with her bratty delivery. I'm sure the fact she is gorgeous helped and she was always really great with fans after the show. Even my cousin who is nearly 70 loved her the best out of all of them.
I did not mean that I think Mack is bad in any way, she is great fun. As I said the touring Cleves is pretty much exactly the same and I thought she was very good, I just prefer the sly, cool way Alexia plays it. Our Aragon is played more in the style of Mack's Cleves, so I think that is why she plays her differently or they would be too similar. As you say each to their own x.