Tonya Pinkins: Then we had a "Lot's Wife" last June that was my personal favorite. I'm still trying to get them to let me sing it at some performance where we get to sing an excerpt that's gone.
Tony Kushner: You can sing it at my funeral.
Tonya Pinkins: Then we had a "Lot's Wife" last June that was my personal favorite. I'm still trying to get them to let me sing it at some performance where we get to sing an excerpt that's gone.
Tony Kushner: You can sing it at my funeral.
She was an incredible Eponine in the 02 concert. Glad to see an actual musical theater singer is in the role. Sorry, but I dreaded Swift's portrayal of Eponine.
If this had anything to with backlash coming from the internet than Hooper and Mackintosh are chickens. They need to grow up and grow backbones! Barks is talented, but this is WAY TOO SAFE of a choice!
Thank the good and merciful Lord above. I must say that Taylor Swift did not raise the bar very high- I'd be happy to hear that nearly anyone else was playing the role.
Thank god some real talent is involved in the younger majority of this cast! She's a great singer, I'm excited to see the movie with her! Her Eponine was spot on in the O2 concert
To be fair they never actually confirmed Taylor. Seems to me they had her over, did some work with her and then realised she wasn't up to the job, gelling with Redmayne, whatever, and got rid. I don't doubt for a second that Cameron Mackintosh isn't fully aware of all the interweb backlash either. Does it really matter how they came to the decision, lets just be pleased they did. I'd have actually take Lea Michelle over Swift but great news for Samantha Barks, she's a known quantity for them and I'm sure she'll be fantastic.
She's a little too squeaky-clean for me in that clip. She sings the song with a really nice voice, but I'm missing that "interesting" quality that Frances Ruffelle had in the original. She was the best thing in the show when I saw the OBC, IMO.
Banks is certainly capable in this concert clip, but I don't see anything unique about it at all. I hope she'll go way beyond this in the film.
"How can Samantha be considered a "safe" choice? She is unknown in Hollywood. She was cast purely on talent unlike the previously rumored ingenue"
She's too safe of a choice acting and singing wise because she's already payed this role before. Jackman, Crowe, Hathaway, Seyfried, and Tveit have never been in this musical. Still no official confirmation on Bonham-Carter and Baren Cohen tough.
"I don't doubt for a second that Cameron Mackintosh isn't fully aware of all the interweb backlash either."
I'm hoping she'll surprise me under Tom Hooper's direction and give a more "personal" and unique performance. I've no doubt she tested (and tested and tested) for the part before they cast her. She must have blown them away.
But going purely on the concert video of her Eponine "as is," I'd say no thank you. She's got "all the right moves" without going beyond a conventional interpretation.
Still, I can't see calling her a "safe" choice. People will definitely go in with a preconceived notion of what she'll do with the part, though.
Hopefully, in the movie (a new medium, new direction, new approach, etc.), she'll rise to the occasion and give us something more memorable.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
Film is the director's medium unlike on stage where the actress can have more control of her interpretation. He can choose the best parts of the different shots and edit them the way wants to. It is also more intimate so I'm hoping Tom Hooper can bring out the subtleties in her performance. At least he will be molding a medium that is good to begin with.
"But going purely on the concert of her Eponine "as is," I'd say no thank you. She's got "all the right moves" without going beyond a conventional interpretation."