Saw it tonight and have some scattered thoughts. First off they have curtained off half of the mezz, and the Broadway looks like the Barrymore or something.
I've listened to the London cast recording quite a bit, but never saw the show there so I can only judge changes through that. There is a fair amount of dialogue on the CD and almost none of it exists as is in the show.
Biggest disappointment is they cut Do The Sacred Mass!! I was pretty downbeat about that. They still have a scene in the bar, but it's totally boring and pointless without the song. The show is also in dire need of some energy earlier in the first act and this song would have done the trick. I hope they consider popping it back in.
Basically when it hits Raise You Voice the show bursts alive. Too bad it takes so long to get to that point. The show is (obviously) best when focused on Patina and the nuns. All the songs for the guys are fine, but nothing special and distract from the real fun of the show. The romance with Patina and Chester Gregory seems forced and unnecessary.
Patina is giving a total star performance and I think she will have fairly smooth sailing accepting that Tony in June. So far I don't think anyone has out-performed her, but I guess we should wait for Donna Murphy.
I did enjoy myself and think the show is a fun time. With a few trims (and the reintroduction of Sacred Mass please) I think it could have a healthy run.
Assuming the five front runners for Best Musical will be Scottsboro, Book of Mormon, Priscilla, Catch Me if You Can and Sister Act, I think it will be interesting to see which one doesn't make the cut. Having now seen all five I think/hope Scottsboro, Mormon, Sister Act all make it and the last spot can be fought for by the other two.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!
Updated On: 3/25/11 at 12:17 AM