I, too, saw the original production and loved it. Yes, the book had problems, but the score was (and is) marvelous. The sweeping title song was a favorite of mine and it was one of the few albums my mother would ask me to play again and again.
I guess the show suffered from Gower Champion's intrigue with photographic projections onstage. These projections were often built into the production numbers and got a bit annoying as the show went on.
I recall a lively production number with the boys that built and built and built. Was that called "Without Me"? And Goulet's leading lady (Julie Gregg?) was quite lovely.
"Long live God!" (GODSPELL)