Well, it's no Cherry Orchard. Thank goodness. But, it's also not very engaging or interesting. Mark Ruffalo needs a character and a director who can tell him what to do.
I admit to not being an Arthur MIller fan. He's hit or miss with me. I dislike Death Of A Salesman but think Incident At Vichy is Miller's most underrated and one of his best. But, I continue to try and see his work in case I'm missing something. I'm also not a Mark Ruffalo fan and, unfortunately, my companion said to me at intermission, without knowing how I felt about him, "he's like watching paint dry."
Danny DeVito, makes his Broadway debut and he is excellent. He dwarfs Ruffalo who seems to have no character, but I truly believed DeVito, form the minute he walked on stage. I wonder what John Turturro would have brought to the role of Victor. I love Tony Shalhoub and he doesn't disappoint.
I think the play suffers from an intermission. So much of the first act is repetitive and drags. It might have some momentum without the intermission and make you care more what's going to happen.
I agree with Whizzer, you could zone out and come back and not miss anything. My companion dozed for about 5 minutes and picked it right up. Admittedly, it was very warm and stuffy in the theater, tonight.
We debated the set and concluded that it was not an attic, but the top floor of a house that, oddly, had no walls, clouds inside and a bedroom located behind a water tower. Not to mention furniture on the ceiling. We thought it was an odd design and the impressionism didn't really get in the way, but didn't really add to the proceedings.
Overall, this is disappointing, but DeVito, Tony Shalhoub & Jessica Hecht are all fine. It's not the mess of The Cherry Orchard, but it needs some stronger direction from Terry Kinney and I hope Mark Ruffalo works through it as previews continue.