rpvee said: "What are you talking about? This wasn’t a commercial. It was a full performance of two songs, and in freezing cold no less."
Watch it again. It was an abbreviated version of "Answer Me", followed by the Overture.
"How is it different from any other daytime program musical performance where a singer may be performing their new single trying to sell it?"
It's not. But there are instances (i.e., SNLs guest musicians) where their performance is specifically designed for TV. Some are pretty creatively designed and executed considering SNL's small space.
I happen to agree with everythingtaboo: "To me, an Outstanding Musical Performance should go to something created from scratch for television." There are examples where this exists - James Cordon's Crosswalk musicals/carpool karaoke, David Letterman's historic Sonny and Cher reunion where they sang "I Got You Babe" (yes, that's an old example), Christmas specials, RENT Live, etc.
I would also point out that there was very little in that Band's Visit promo that creatively used skills typically, or distinctly utilized in television production. The cast was great - but that's because they reproduced what was designed and rehearsed for the theater.
Updated On: 5/5/19 at 08:56 AM