I caught this last night and I'm in the camp of people who weren't fans. What it does have going for it are the performances. Everyone is very committed to the material, and Kudisch is certainly doing fine work, but I just didn't care about his character. Horrible things were happening to the characters, but the events just washed over me without eliciting a single emotional response.
I did enjoy some of the music, and certainly found it interesting, but the lyrics were near dreadful. I felt they neither propelled the story nor character development. It was like each song stopped what little momentum the show had dead in its tracks.
The ambitious projections obviously were made with much care and attention to detail, but I often found myself more wrapped up with them than the action on stage.
I left the theater with my friends saying more WTF than, "wow, that was amazing!" (The audience as a whole was cold as ice. No applause or reaction to anything nearly the whole show.)
At the end of the day I want to ask the creators the question they posed to the audience at the top of the production: why? Why are you telling us this story? It has to be more than a bizarre history lesson. I'm sure in a few weeks this will merely be a cobwebbed memory: floof it's gone.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!