Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

The Importance of Being Earnest -- first preview — Page 4

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#76

The Importance of Being Earnest -- first preview

So when I say his performance was adequate, I mean just that. It was adequate. Not extraordinary, which it SHOULD have been.

Ahhh...but, you see, that is merely your opinion and not a fact.

To me, and to many others, Brian Bedford's performance as Lady Bracknell is extraordinary. I heard things in the dialogue I had never heard before: nuance, wit, aspects of social position and class structure.

That you think the performance was "adequate" might have more to do with your expectations than his performance.

I would suggest you see it again. I know I want to.
#77

The Importance of Being Earnest -- first preview

I might return, PJ, and you might be right. I might like it more the second time. I didn't, however, actually go in with high expectations. I went in with a curiosity and nothing more. I didn't really hear new things in the dialogue the way you did. To me, it didn't seem any different than many Bracknells I had seen (I am aware that this is an opinion and not fact, but it's an opinion based in my past experiences as an audience member). I never claimed that it was a fact that the performance wasn't extraordinary. I personally didn't find it extraordinary, but that's not to say that other people won't find it as such. To each his own.
#78

The Importance of Being Earnest -- first preview

An admirably restrained response, bjh.

Isn't it a bit redundant to point out that anyone's expressed opinion is an opinion and not a fact?

I suppose it's possible that the opinions of joey and his coterie are facts, and everyone else's opinions are just opinions, but that doesn't sound quite right...
#79

The Importance of Being Earnest -- first preview

I will never get the Edith Evans performance out of my head, bjh. I could be lying in a coma for years and the first words out of my mouth might her sweeping upward inflection "A haaaaaannnnd...baaaaagg?" or her short, staccato "Prism! Where? Is? That? Beh-beh!"

But her performance is a wild, wonderful larger-than-life caricature, in many ways more like an American drag queen or a British travesty role than an actual, real woman.

I think Bedford made a bold choice to avoid that kind of artificiality. He is giving a surprisingly small, quiet performance in the role--opting to find the humor in Wilde's dialogue than in the size of the character. It's a bold choice because he risks disappointing people who are going in thinking they are going to see something wild. (Wilde?)

But, in the end, when I wake up from that coma, I think I may remember Brian Bedford's sad bewilderment at hearing Jack describe being left at a railway station just as much as I remember Edith Evans's high dudgeon.

And I think Wilde would be pleased.
#81

The Importance of Being Earnest -- first preview

Somewhere between 8 and 10 I'd say. Not all professional productions, but some of them were. The last professional production I saw, not counting Ernest in Love at the Irish Rep last season (Beth Fowler was a hoot), was the Pearl Theatre Company production back in 2008. Carol Schultz was glorious in that production.
#83

The Importance of Being Earnest -- first preview

Of course I have! And I do love Edith Evans. I must say, though, that Judi Dench holds a special place in my heart if we're talking movie versions.
#85

The Importance of Being Earnest -- first preview

I'm glad neither of you took the bait to start the fight he seemed to want.

But I'll risk one by saying that though there's lots to love about that movie, Dench is a bit too quiet for my taste. (And obviously all these discussions are about personal taste.) I haven't seen Bedford yet--I hope to--but I wonder if I'll feel the same way bhj did.

Updated On: 12/23/10 at 05:03 PM

#87

The Importance of Being Earnest -- first preview

But I'll risk one by saying that though there's lots to love about that movie, Dench is a bit too quiet for my taste.

That's actually one of the things I love most about her portrayal. I love that she is both quiet and EXTREMELY dry. I lot of Bracknell's play the part with sass or sarcasm. Judi played the part like she was above it all. I thought it was brilliant.
#88

The Importance of Being Earnest -- first preview

Yes, I can see. I just wished she'd been a bit funnier.

It actually sounds like what you liked about Dench is what PJ liked about Bedford.
#90

The Importance of Being Earnest -- first preview

Finally saw a preview this week and having seen Bedford's production at Stratford, I am pleased to say that this is a HUGE improvement in every way. The casting is wonderful and if this doesn't make Santino Fontana a big Broadway name, I suspect nothing will. I also imagine that he will be scooped up for film and TV so it may also be a bit of a swan song. David Furr is also wonderful, witty and terribly sexy. Sara Topham is another hold-over from Stratford and she is just delicious as is the terrific Charlotte Parry who I had loved in the Peter Hall production of a few years ago.And what can you say about Ivey and Whitehead? They are without flaw. And as for Beford, I still haven't lost my philosophical dislike of men playing this great woman's role, but he is just a treat, with timing you could set a clock to. He commands the stage with a flick of an eye or some other subtle gesture. With all the BIG acting on Broadway right now, what a lesson to see Bedford hold an audience with his artistry. I don't know what happened between Stratford and New York, but for my money it is another level of performance. Go see it!!!
#91

The Importance of Being Earnest -- first preview

Glad to hear it! I can't wait for Sunday!
If we're not having fun, then why are we doing it? These are DISCUSSION boards, not mutual admiration boards. Discussion only occurs when we are willing to hear what others are thinking, regardless of whether it is alignment to our own thoughts.
#92

The Importance of Being Earnest -- first preview

Would this be a good production to see as a first introduction to the play? It somehow has eluded me thus far (though I may have seen a film version years ago but don't remember it if I did), and this sounds intriguing.
"Art, in itself, is an attempt to bring order out of chaos."-Stephen Sondheim
#93

The Importance of Being Earnest -- first preview

While I wouldn't go so far to say it was the best thing since baked bread (or whatever the saying is), I definitely would recommend it as a first viewing. There is nothing inherently WRONG with it and I'm glad to see Roundabout FINALLY doing something right.
BroadwayEd
#94

The Importance of Being Earnest -- first preview

Ed, it's sliced bread.
Anyone else see Maggie Smith in the West End in '93?
She was magical and Bob Crowley's sets were perfectly striking.

Can't wait to see Bedford, who loves wearing frocks.
One of the most fun, intelligent gents to work with.
#95

The Importance of Being Earnest -- first preview

It would then be my first experience with the show, my first Roundabout, and actually my first straight play on Broadway. Lots of firsts!
"Art, in itself, is an attempt to bring order out of chaos."-Stephen Sondheim
#96

The Importance of Being Earnest -- first preview

"There is nothing inherently WRONG with it and I'm glad to see Roundabout FINALLY doing something right."

Eh, this isn't so much Roundabout's production. It's a transfer, much like the rest of the most successful Roundabout productions over the last few years.
"...everyone finally shut up, and the audience could enjoy the beginning of the Anatevka Pogram in peace."
#98

The Importance of Being Earnest -- first preview

Bwayfan--this production would make a great introduction to the play. Wilde's wit sparkles in every performance, down to Lane the butler.

Then watch the Edith Evans and then the Judi Dench, and you'll know the play and Wilde's worldview inside out.

And I'm sure Oscar would have something terribly witty to say about Earnest being your first "straight" play.
#99

The Importance of Being Earnest -- first preview

I think this would make a better option than the mess that is Spider-Man.

Now I just need to figure out this rush or Hiptix thing...Roundabout has too many options!
"Art, in itself, is an attempt to bring order out of chaos."-Stephen Sondheim
#100

The Importance of Being Earnest -- first preview

^Funny. I'm seeing both this weekend!
If we're not having fun, then why are we doing it? These are DISCUSSION boards, not mutual admiration boards. Discussion only occurs when we are willing to hear what others are thinking, regardless of whether it is alignment to our own thoughts.

Latest Posts

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $73
Hot Show
Tickets From $89
Hot Show
Tickets From $89
Hot Show
Tickets From $65