I also was at the show, and I brave the firestorm and make a few comments. For the first preview, this cast is in amazing shape. They are much more cohesive than the Chicago cast was in their first few shows, and that's not a slam against the Chicago cast, for those of you sensitive types.
Just a few comments on a few people...
Rick Faugno is a very intense Frankie, and I really like his falsetto. Andrew Rannells has a cute sort of Dennis the Menace all grown up kind of thing going on-- it worked well. Bryan McElroy is doing sort of a larger than life Italian Stallion thing, complete with lots of large gestures, which felt a bit... big to me, but the portrayal makes sense and it will be interesting to see where he takes it. Jeff Leibow is maybe more to the Steve Gouveia side of things, very quiet yet very good at the exasperation.
I really liked Joyce Chittick as Mary. She is tough as nails, with a devil may care bad girl attitude, which gets stripped away to a pathetic cry into her drink when she and Frankie break up. Lauren Tartaglia (on for Julia Krohn) has a lot of nice details and fun expressions in her roles, which was fun to see. Ken Krugman was amusing as Gyp-- he's quite tall and reminded me a bit of Brent Spiner.
Some weird costuming stuff going on (Vegasified?), like the bling bling rappers, who look like they got attacked by a rogue bedazzler. There was a shiny purple coat with fur, and so many random shiny things in general. The usual different fabrics here and there, the most notable of which was giant bows on the Angels, and a new orange dress. Huh.
If anyone really wants to know details about something in particular, that might be arranged. I look forward to seeing this cast settle in.
'"Contrairiwise," continued Tweedledee, "if it was so, it might be; and if it were so, it would be; but as it isn't, it ain't. That's logic."'
~Lewis Carroll