I'm a tad tired to give a lot of details, so I'll give you the short version of the details.
I cried through most of the show. First of all, this was my parents' favorite show, and May 7 is the day my Dad passed away. My sister and I used to sing "Young Phyllis" and "Young Sally" while my mom was the grown-up women. (She had an amazing voice, my mother.) Naturally, my Dad was all the men. So, I felt very connected to the original production, which I know by heart. (Seeing Sondheim outside the theatre before curtain also took me back.)
Jan Maxwell stole the show. BEST Phyllis I have ever seen. SHE seems like the star, not Bernadette. She is breathtakingly beautiful (and 55! God love her!); her dramatic scenes are devastating; and she sells every number with panache. I have loved her for a long time, but now I am smitten!
Danny Burstein's "God Why Don't You Love Me Blues" was PERFECT. It's exactly what you imagine Danny Burstein's take on the number would be. He is by turns goofy and heartbreaking.
Bernadette Peters appeared to have a little voice trouble tonight, and I don't think she has nailed Sally yet. But she's Bernadette, so she'll be fabulous by tomorrow.
Ron Raines is, for me, the greatest surprise. His acting, singing and posture were just pitch-perfect. His breakdown at the end is absolutely gut-wrenching. I was really impressed by him.
Linda Lavin does a great "Broadway Baby." It's like she just stepped out of the Orpheum Circuit.
Elaine Paige is precisely what you think Carlotta would be like. She's got a no-nonsense air about her and yet is engaging and charismatic.
Terri White brings down the house! Why doesn't this woman have a Tony????
Rosalind Elias is just darling. She's what every one of us on Broadway World wishes our grandmother was like! And Leah Horowitz, who plays Young Heidi, has a truly lovely voice.
Susan Watson is adorable! I can't beleive she's almost 70! Kim? Nanette? Still has that bubbly, perky personality too.
The ghosts are mesmerizing and GORGEOUS, as are the costumes. I am very biased about Gregg Barnes; I think he's the best costume designer in the theatre today.
The set is eerie and dazzling. Derek McLane is understated all the way.
Choreography = superb. Warren Carlysle really uses all the women to their best advantage.
Eric Schaeffer should be very pleased tonight. I happen to find him an excellent interpreter of Sondheim's work. But tonight was a triumph beyond words, IMO.
If this show does not transfer, I will be shocked!
BTW...the ending is NOT the Roundabout's (thank gawd) and Sally DOES mention suicide.
Oh, and the "Young" characters are fine, especially Sally, Buddy and Phyllis. Young Sally and Buddy are like spitting images of Bernadette and Danny. I also think the actress who plays Margie, Kiira Schmitt, is a riot!
I hope this helps.
"Be on your guard! Jerks on the loose!"
http://www.roches.com/television/ss83kod.html
**********
"If any relationship involves a flow chart, get out of it...FAST!"
~ Best12Bars