I just took a group of theater-obsessed students to see a professional regional musical production. We reviewed the rules before. We talked about what to do and not to do. All through Act 1, a bunch of kids talked, commented, questioned, and could not sit still. These were 8th graders by the way. I was too seated too far from this particular group to stop them during the show without causing a major disturbance of my own.
At intermission, I gave them a stern lecture and reminded them to not talk and to sit still. So they were good through Act 2. Then, the next day at school, one of them informs me that they are all protesting MY rudeness by not being part of the school musical production next fall. They understand that phones are bad, but they vigorously defended their right to quietly talk and make comments in live theater if only the people who are talking can actually hear them.
Normally students that I take to theater are perfectly behaved. But the world seems to be moving closer and closer to a place where we just have to give up and try our best to hear and see the show over the distractions. I know I am ready to give up.