JBroadway, we must have seen each other at the stage door! I was the young man at the end of the line :)
I think I enjoyed this performance more than others in this thread. I love the subject matter - Anna Karenina is one of my favorite films of the past few years and I thought this was very much in the same vein. The set and lighting are absolutely marvelous - you feel the freedom Therese is longing for in the vast stage. I loved the apartment set and how it closed up the actors and trapped them in the small space. Laurent's apartment with the stars was the highlight of both the set and the show for me. The river serves its purpose well and really brings life to the climactic conclusion of the first act. My only quibble was the length it took to change the set, which killed the momentum and pacing of the show.
I didn't really like the adaptation. I felt that the dialogue was rather stilted - I first thought that it was intentional as the first few scenes between Therese and Laurent seemed more free, but I don't think that was the case. The show feels very expositional in the first act - the only life I felt was in the sex scenes. The second act was emotional payoff and I enjoyed it a lot more. I thought the physical return of Camille didn't have the impact it needed to. The ending was very problematic and needs to be worked on. I wasn't devastated at their ruin - I barely felt anything which needs to be addressed. I bought the script afterwards and saw this was the last part of the show: "THERESE begins to hear the sounds of the river. The sounds she heard in her youth. A free-flowing river, rushing, full of life and possibilities. The swans take flight. She raises her head, to watch them in the sky. Then she falls forward, into LAURENT's falling body. They lie entwined and twisted on the floor. And MADAME RAQUIN stares down at them, her eyes full of triumph." None of that happened. That feels satisfying, but at the moment, Laurent and Therese just lie on a table and blackout. Nothing felt like a conclusion.
The acting was uniformly strong. Keira Knightley was fantastic. She made me watch her in the first 45 minutes where she barely says anything. Her eyes are alive. She was very convincing and made a wonderful debut - I hope she returns soon. Her breakdown was fantastic and she brings everything she does to films to the theater. Her character would benefit to a more intimate space or close ups, but she was facinating to watch. Judith Light has a tough character, but she really wrings the most out of it. Interestingly enough, the last half hour, where she says nothing, was gorgeous. Everything she needs to say, she says with her eyes and that was breathtaking. Matt Ryan was fantastic and brought shading to a complicated character. Gabriel Ebert does his best with a truly hateful and selfish character. Poor Mary Wiseman was a standout in a thankless role (which I felt could have used more material - a scene with her and Therese?) and the rest of the cast was wonderful. I just wish the script was better.
I do think it would have made a more compelling film or musical than a straight play. Therese has such a complex inner life that would have been great in song. In fact, she reminds me of Fosca in that first 45 minutes. The show is really up LaChiusa's ally (very Marie Christine / Bernarda Alba) and I wish Keira could sing (can she?). It would be wonderful, I think.
The stage door was good, Keira signed very fast and left, but she got to everyone. Judith Light was fantastic and spoke to me - she is wonderful.
I had some very rude people behind me (one was on her phone) and I missed most of the first 10 minutes due to talking and crinkling. They then yelled when the usher confronted them at intermission. It was atrocious. I thanked the user after the show - the poor people at the theater must be fed up with awful people by now. All in all, an interesting experience with some wonderful performances. I recommend it if you have the means, but it is by no means a must see (unless they do some serious work during previews, which, in the age, is doubtful).
"Sticks and stones, sister. Here, have a Valium." - Patti LuPone, a Memoir