This may be the most visually stunning production of a play I have ever seen. Truly remarkable work.
I thought this was great production overall, but I agree with some of the pacing and tone issues that other posters have identified. I didn't feel like any single scene was superfluous, but I wish some of them moved along at a faster clip. The drama and tension certainly unfold as a slow burn, but there are some scenes especially early in the first act that could move faster. I also agree that there were moments in the second act that should have had dramatic heft that garnered laughter from the audience. One in particular, in which: (spoiler) Therese and Laurent are having one of their final arguments with the ghost of Camille sitting at the table and Laurent screams at Therese that she should take the ghost with her if she leaves him, that got a large - inappropriate - chuckle out of the crowd. (end spoiler) They have to fix some of those moments tonally to have a bigger impact at the end of the show.
The core quartet of actors are all delivering solid-to-remarkable performances. The weak(er) link in the cast is Matt Ryan who, although very good, has not yet established the right chemistry with Knightley. I was impressed with Gabriel Ebert. Going into the production with the little knowledge I had of the characters, I expected Camille to be cruel; I thought the juvenility and arrogance that Ebert brought to the character made him stifling and insufferable, but also brought enough comic relief in the first act that brightened what could have been an otherwise dour proceeding. Keira Knightley and Judith Light are truly the acting highlights of the production. I agree with all of the other comments that what they are able to convey in their extended silences are just as impactful, if not more so, than their scenes verbally and physically interacting with the characters around them. This is a very respectful and smart Broadway debut from Knightley. And this is another great role for Light. Although I think she had more meaty material in Other Desert Cities and The Assembled Parties, she brings a lot nuance and even pathos to a role that I expected to be much more one note. She's such a gem on the stage and I hope she continues coming back to the stage.
I have to comment on the observations of how this becomes a "ghost story" in the second act. (spoilers) The first two times when Camille physically enters a scene with just his hand were surprising and shocked and frightened a great deal of the people sitting around me. When he actually walks into the room and later when he is sitting at the table, they're less shocking, but even more chilling and, I think, important symbolically. The transition from him intruding on quiet, private moments in the bedroom ever so briefly to his full body presence to me represents Therese and Laurent's fuller acknowledging of their guilt and crime and their growing inability to come to terms with it (end spoilers). I'll be revisiting the show in November, and am very exciting to see how the production will have shaped up by then.
Also a note about the stage door, all four of the leads came out very quickly this evening. Matt didn't sign for everybody, but he did pose for pictures and was gracious. Keira seemed to be in more of a rush than previous reports, as she scribbled on a few books and playbills and dashed to the car; she certainly didn't get to everyone in the line, but the crowd did appear to be very large. Gabriel was there for a quiet a long time, posing for pictures and signing and chatting with fans. And as usual, Judith was very giving of her time. I had brought a picture of her and I at the stage door of Assembled Parties for her to sign, and she seemed quite happy to see it. We talked for a moment, and then she moved on to sign other books. She came back to me a few minutes later, though, saying that she wanted to see the picture again so that she could personalize it. She's just so incredibly sweet.
Wow, apologies for the length of this post! I guess I had a lot of thoughts to share and react to on this one!
Updated On: 10/4/15 at 02:32 PM