Turn Your Phone OFF!!!!!

Of course I don't condone the recent shooting in a movie theater over texting, but I have to admit, I almost understand.

I am so over sitting next to - or near - someone who is checking their phone during a live performance. I always nicely ask the person to please turn off their phone and inevitably they will, but a few minutes later, they're checking their phone again. I would never take out a gun - I don't own one - but it makes my blood boil.

I honestly do wish that some blocking technology would be developed and employed at theaters. Doctors and/or other professionals who have a legitimate need to remain in contact during a live performance can leave their phones at some designated window outside of the blocked area (coat check?) with their seat assignment.

In addition, if you are a professional who must be on call, then you should make sure your seats are on the aisle.

Texting - mobile phone usage - has no place in a Broadway theater unless it is integrated into the production as a unique feature.

---

Hmm, that isn't necessarily true, since the building itself could just include material that doesn't allow the signal to pass through it, in which case everything inside the box would be able to communicate, but nothing from outside could make it inside.

Apple does have a patent on performers or venues using IR (I think) technology to send a signal that would disallow iPhones from shooting video, or photos, or using Flash at the discretion of the venue/performers. But no word if that is currently in the operating system or not. Even if it were, that would only affect iPhone users, so it would still need to be a standard before other devices would support it.

Once that happened, pirate apps or jailbroken phones would still disable the Apple signal, so at a certain level you can't really stop it without signal-proofing the whole building.

That said, there are cell jammers on the market, which are illegal. And it would mean no one around you would be able to receive calls, send text, or check their feeds. Again, which would be illegal.

---

I obviously hate it too--but in this case it seemed even more ridiculous--wasn't the guy texting during the ads/previews at the movie? I mean, I try not to do that, but it seems fair enough (similarly I wouldn't object to someone texting at intermission during a play...)

Your obsession with this has made you lose all sense and logic, Scott Briefer. You're forgetting that cell jammers (and legislation that might support it) bring in serious security and safety issues. There is then no way for someone to call in an emergency on their personal phone or receive emergency calls/texts/etc.

Try again, Scott. Try again.

So, I work in a front of house position that lets me observe which patrons' phones make noises and how they respond. I really believe that the vast majority of interruptions are from people who genuinely forgot to set their phone to silent. It's been on very rare occasion that I've seen a patron actually take a call and act as though it was their right to do so. I think that we could vastly improve the theatrical experience for people if we could make it much harder for well-intentioned audience members to forget to silence their devices.

My solution: Make a default setting on smartphones that responds to a local signal (perhaps a bluetooth or wifi device broadcasting a specific ID) and sets the device to silent. It should be enabled by default, but the user should be able to set the device to "opt out" of the silencing, either on a one-time basis or on a permanent basis.

Pros: Users who have a need to keep their device unsilenced can do so. While I don't think there are many such users, maybe something will come up in the future. This also avoids the use of active jammers, which are not only illegal, but risk interfering with show control systems. And it avoids the use of passive jammers (like Faraday cages in the wallpaper or whatever) which is a brute force solution and disallows all use of devices, including pre-show, intermission, and post-show. And there are often good reasons for theatre staff or show crew to have working devices. And in case of an emergency, passive jamming remains in place, hampering rescue efforts.

Cons: Doesn't prevent intentional use, either phone calls or texting. Would be unlikely to ever work on non-smart phones. And the biggest con of all -- it seems quite unlikely to ever be implemented by smartphone device makers or software writers.

So the reality is that I doubt it'll ever happen. But whenever I see this discussion, I like to throw it out there, just in case someone with the power to unilaterally add a feature into all smartphones happens to be reading. Personally, I have my devices set up to respond to calendar events and automatically silence when I'm in a show.

kmccoy2 for president!

---

It seems to me the answer is easy. Simply place a retired police officer with a gun in every theatre. Problem solved.

I think that age comes into play as well. I recall watching a local news story that was talking about cellphone usage in the theatre. This was also around the time that a patron's cell phone stopped a New York Philharmonic concert. It was later discovered that the patron was an elderly man who didn't fully know how to use their new smartphone and genuinely felt embarrassed and genuinely felt bad for what happened.

The news story pointed out that a majority of people's phone's that go off are older. And, people that don't really know how to use the newer smartphones that are out there. It also stated that younger people know not only how to turn their phones off, but know to do so when in the theatre.

Personally, I feel that while it is easy to say that if you don't know how to use a smartphone you shouldn't have one. I feel that it is more complicated than that. I think that there are people who are older that get frustrated over not knowing how to use the newer technology and that admitting defeat in that regard can be a bitter pill to take.

---

"Of course I don't condone the recent shooting in a movie theater over texting, but I have to admit, I almost understand."

Sorry, can't compute that. The two events should never even be in the same sentence.

While I agree it's an annoyance and a huge problem for performers AND for audience members to deal with phones, IPads, etc...and it certainly needs to be dealt with, it's a little daunting to read that while you don't condone what happened of course, you could almost understand it. You almost understand wanting to blow someone's head off...shooting them in the face in front of his/her spouse...killing them... because you are distracted in a theater?

I am sure you didn't mean it literally but still - there is enough violence in the world without "almost understanding"(even in jest) another gun tragedy.

Sorry if I have offended..you just hit a sore spot with me.

Updated On: 1/15/14 at 10:39 AM

winston89... I disagree with your post 1 million percent. The woman sitting next to me last week was a 30 something. The woman sitting next to me a few weeks ago, who actually made a call during the performance was also a 30 something. The young man who refused to turn off his game on his smartphone was barely a teen. The young woman in front of me who kept texting was also a teen. The list goes on.

It may be true that older people struggle with the technology and perhaps those incredibly inappropriate moments when a phone goes off may be attributed to those who don't understand the technology, from my experience, the vast - as in ALL - of those who believe that keeping their mobile devices on during a performance are young seemingly tech knowledgable people.

If you extend this to other inappropriate usage of mobile devices and texting outside of the theater, it is my three 20 something nephews who can't seem to turn off their phones, even when driving. I have never been in my father's car when he took out his phone while driving!

I love my iPhone. Professional, I actually design apps for the device. I am a strong believer in technology. I am an early adapter. I just think there is a time and a place and after years and years of hearing that the etiquette of such devices needs time to work itself out, I have lost my patience as things seem to be only getting worse.

It is time that we - the culture at large - have a debate about such issues and take appropriate action. Either I have to give up my passion for the theater and accept that I am in the minority and texting in the theater is here to stay, or universally we have to educate those who haven't had the appropriate upbringing.

---

Updated On: 1/15/14 at 10:46 AM

Perhaps I am just the unluckiest person, as I am often seated next to the person who can't seem to turn their device off.

---

I actually have often purchased and consumed popcorn, candy and soda at a movie. I have no issue with this at all and having worked as an usher at a movie theater when I was a kid, so I am well aware that the concession is the primary source of revenue for a movie theater.

I was referring to those patrons who arrive at the theater with a concealed 20pc KFC dinner and proceed to turn their movie experience into their home dining room table experience despite the theater being quite full and their actions spilling over to all those around them... Can you please pass me a leg and some of those fries. YUM!!! Oh... I could use a napkin. Ugh. What am I going to do with these bones? I'll just throw them on the floor.

---

Updated On: 1/15/14 at 11:21 AM

^ I didn't know the word... Just did a google search... cool. Thank you Wynbish. I'm off to learn about "goosfraba"

---