Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

West Side Story revival? — Page 7

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#151

West Side Story revival?

I think it's too soon for another WSS revival on. The last one recouped but got mixed reviews and turned some people off. And the PC police have only gotten more strident in the past decade. For a 62-year old show involving racial tensions, that's not good news. Other harbingers of problems to come: the director, the cast of unknowns, the 'brand new' choreography....none of this bodes well for this production.

#152

West Side Story revival?

I was extremely excited about this production but now I'm... not. I was at performance of Carousel right after this all become public and Ramasar's entrance was met with total silence. Totally warranted and so uncomfortable, besides his Jigger being perhaps the worst acting I've seen recently.

Very happy for Powell and Pimentel, but aside from that, no other good news.

#153

West Side Story revival?

I hope the majority of responses here are echoed throughout the rest of the theatre community and lead to a replacement before previews start. Even if you choose to ignore the scandal there's still the issue of his acting. Make no mistake, I'm extremely excited for this production and super elated they're giving so many fresh faces the opportunity to bring this story to life in a new way, I just don't want this controversy to follow the show all the way to its opening.

Considering we are going to be getting reworkings of both WWS and Company this season, the revival category will surely be more exciting than this past season.

#154

West Side Story revival?

Isaac is very talented, and I love his singing voice. He certainly has the attention-grabbing presence for a lead at the very least. Tony is also similar to Daniel’s lovestruck, wide-eyed character- in short, I think it’s an exciting casting choice. Most of the cast is filled with “who are they?” actors and dancers, but I think some of that fresh blood could help this (admittedly) stale show feel new again. If this is taking place in the present day or some sort of anachronistic mix- which all of the promotional pictures seem to be indicating- the mixed race Jets casting would make sense. Still not sure how I feel about that.

No surprise that Rudin would allow Ramasar cast, but it sure is disappointing. I don’t want to support a show that will willingly employ someone with such a vile track record; a shame since the rest of the cast is quite interesting.
#155

West Side Story revival?

Ramasar aside, I'm very excited for this new cast, especially with so many debuts. It'll be great to see so many fresh faces, especially if many of them of are teenagers, to help make this production and new choreography feel more present and timely.




"Hey little girls, look at all the men in shiny shirts and no wives!" - Jackie Hoffman, Xanadu, 19 Feb 2008
#156

West Side Story revival?

Re: Ramasar, I'm only vaguely familiar with the story.

My understanding is that Zachary Catazaro took pictures of his girlfriend without his consent. Was Ramasar's involvement that he received these pictures?

I'm inclined to believe victims, but I am want to make sure I understand the story first. From there I'll decide if I feel it's right for me to see this production of WSS. Which is a shame, because WSS is one of most favorite musicals.

#157

West Side Story revival?

Kitsune said: "Re: Ramasar, I'm only vaguely familiar with the story.

My understanding is that Zachary Catazaro took pictures of his girlfriend without his consent. Was Ramasar's involvement that he received these pictures?


https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/15/arts/dance/city-ballet-fires-two-male-dancers-accused-of-sharing-photos.html

"In the suit, filed in state Supreme Court in Manhattan, Ms. Waterbury accused Mr. Finlay of sending nude photos of her to Mr. Ramasar, and said Mr. Ramasar had sent back an image of a bare-chested “female ballet member.”"

https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/02/18/what-went-wrong-at-new-york-city-ballet

What she found on the screen was a series of photographs of women’s private parts, including her own, plus a brief clip of her having sex with Finlay.

According to the complaint in a lawsuit that she later filed, there were text messages, too. Finlay, sending someone a photograph of Waterbury naked, asked, “You have any pictures of girls you’ve f*cked? I’ll send you some . . . ballerina girls I’ve made scream and squirt.” The exchanges included several participants, notably two other N.Y.C.B. principals, Amar Ramasar and Zachary Catazaro, and a young donor, Jared Longhitano. “We should get like half a kilo”—of cocaine, one assumes—​“and pour it over the . . . girls and just violate them,” Longhitano wrote to Catazaro and Finlay. “I bet we could tie some of them up and abuse them like farm animals.” “Or like the sluts they are,” Finlay rejoined. “Yeah,” Longhitano wrote back. “I want them to watch me destroy one of their friends. And they know they’re next. I bet we could triple team.” Finlay also reported that he had just “****ed a 20-year-old ballerina and her sister! That was my first threesome with family members. It was incredible!” In another thread, a former student at the ballet school thanked Finlay for sending a picture of himself and Waterbury engaged in a sex act: “I can’t stop looking at Alex’s tits lol.”"

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/19/arts/dance/city-ballet-amar-ramasar-sexually-explicit-texts.html

" Her suit, which accused City Ballet of condoning a “fraternity-like atmosphere,” did not accuse Mr. Catazaro or Mr. Ramasar of sharing material related to her, but said that they had shared sexually explicit texts containing nude images of other women affiliated with the company or the school. "

Updated On: 7/10/19 at 04:38 PM

#158

West Side Story revival?

Just the thought of the 37 year-old Ramasar knifing it out with the 21 year-old Cook is ridiculous enough!

Updated On: 7/10/19 at 04:53 PM

#159

West Side Story revival?

Everyone is under 25, and then there's Amar. Completely off and totally bizarre.

#160

West Side Story revival?

Pardon my possible ignorance here, but Alexander Gemignani is the music director? Does he have previous music direction credits?

#161

West Side Story revival?

I honestly thought that was a mistake and they meant his father, Paul Gemignani. Wowza.

#162

West Side Story revival?

For what it's worth, they have been workshopping this show regularly with this cast since December 2018. If Rudin didn't believe in it, or think it was worth the time/money/drama, he'd ditch it. They're obviously very confident they have a 2019 Oklahoma on their hands. I hope they're right.

#163

West Side Story revival?

leighmiserables said: "Pardon my possible ignorance here, but Alexander Gemignani is the music director? Does he have previous music direction credits?"



i know he stepped in as a sub at Mean Girls fairly recently. I’m sure he has more.


the artist formerly known as dancingthrulife04 Check out my Etsy shop: https://www.etsy.com/shop/dreamanddrift And please consider donating to my Ride to Remember, benefitting the Alzheimer's Association: http://act.alz.org/site/TR?fr_id=8200&pg=personal&px=6681234
#164

West Side Story revival?

VotePeron said: "For what it's worth, they have been workshopping this show regularly with this cast since December 2018. If Rudin didn't believe in it, or think it was worth the time/money/drama, he'd ditch it. They're obviously very confident they have a 2019 Oklahoma on their hands. I hope they're right."

The team definitely wants this to be the next Oklahoma, but there are two problems. First, one of the fundamental rules of creativity is to never try and copy a spontaneous phenomenon. Second of all, West Side Story is opening in the Broadway Theatre, which has double the capacity of Circle in the Square, and is opening "cold" without an Off-Broadway run to build positive word-of-mouth. This new West Side Story could still do reasonably well, but trying to be the new Oklahoma could be an unreliable route to success...

#166

West Side Story revival?

He was Music Director as well as orchestrator and arranger of Roundabout's Merrily earlier this year

Updated On: 7/10/19 at 05:55 PM

#167

West Side Story revival?

ariel175 said: "Rachel Zegler (Movie Maria) seems pleased about most of the cast (one guess for who she's NOT pleased about):

https://twitter.com/rachelzegler/likes
"

Has Spielberg not made her get rid of that Twitter account yet? She seems like a sweetheart, but wow, she certainly doesn't come across as a professional...

Updated On: 7/10/19 at 06:04 PM

#168

West Side Story revival?

MemorableUserName said: "Kitsune said: "Re: Ramasar, I'm only vaguely familiar with the story.

My understanding is that Zachary Catazaro took pictures of his girlfriend without his consent. Was Ramasar's involvement that he received these pictures?


https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/15/arts/dance/city-ballet-fires-two-male-dancers-accused-of-sharing-photos.html

"In the suit, filed in state Supreme Court in Manhattan, Ms. Waterbury accused Mr. Finlay of sending nude photos of her to Mr. Ramasar, and said Mr. Ramasar had sent back an image of a bare-chested “female ballet member.”"

https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/02/18/what-went-wrong-at-new-york-city-ballet

What she found on the screen was a series of photographs of women’s private parts, including her own, plus a brief clip of her having sex with Finlay.

According to the complaint in a lawsuit that she later filed, there were text messages, too. Finlay, sending someone a photograph of Waterbury naked, asked, “You have any pictures of girls you’ve f*cked? I’ll send you some... ballerina girls I’ve made scream and squirt.” The exchanges included several participants, notably two other N.Y.C.B. principals, Amar Ramasar and Zachary Catazaro, and a young donor, Jared Longhitano. “We should get like half a kilo”—of cocaine, one assumes—?“and pour it over the... girls and just violate them,” Longhitano wrote to Catazaro and Finlay. “I bet we could tie some of them up and abuse them like farm animals.” “Or like the sluts they are,” Finlay rejoined. “Yeah,” Longhitano wrote back. “I want them to watch me destroy one of their friends. And they know they’re next. I bet we could triple team.” Finlay also reported that he had just “****ed a 20-year-old ballerina and her sister! That was my first threesome with family members. It was incredible!” In another thread, a former student at the ballet school thanked Finlay for sending a picture of himself and Waterbury engaged in a sex act: “I can’t stop looking at Alex’s tits lol.”"

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/19/arts/dance/city-ballet-amar-ramasar-sexually-explicit-texts.html

" Her suit, which accused City Ballet of condoning a “fraternity-like atmosphere,” did not accuse Mr. Catazaro or Mr. Ramasar of sharing material related to her, but said that they had shared sexually explicit texts containing nude images of other women affiliated with the company or the school. "
"

It's still not clear here. Did Ramasar take the photos he had with permission or not? That makes a huge difference. The rest is just dirty talk, and like all dirty talk is offensive or not depending on the individual, but not threatening or criminal. If he photographed a woman's body without her consent, that's a crime. If he forced a woman to do something she didn't want, that's a crime. But did he?

Updated On: 7/10/19 at 06:12 PM

#169

West Side Story revival?

It's still not clear here. Did Ramasar take the photos he had with permission or not? That makes a huge difference. The rest is just dirty talk, and like all dirty talk is offensive or not depending on the individual, but not threatening or criminal. If he photographed a woman's body without her consent, that's a crime. If he forced a woman to do something she didn't want, that's a crime. But did he?

Whether he did or not, sharing nude pictures/videos that a) a woman sent to a completely different person, or b) a woman didn't know were taken is vile and disgusting and wrong, whether or not it is illegal. It is ridiculous that people are saying things like "she should have known better." That's ridiculous. The men involved should have behaved better. It is not her fault, even if she did voluntarily participate in the picture.

The fascination of the legality of this is confusing, especially since most of the negativity has not been about him breaking the law. Instead, people are horrified that someone would participate in such behavior, never deny it, never apologize for it (that I have ever seen publicly acknowledged), and yet still faces no significant consequences.

Whether he is the most talented triple-threat in the world or not shouldn't matter, as a person who participates in that type of behavior should not continue to get high-profile opportunities without some sort of penance.

#170

West Side Story revival?

If she willingly took or sent the photos, yes, she should have known better. That's just common sense. You take these kinds of pictures, or share them, you run the risk. As an adult, you have to own that.

Doesn't make him any less slimy. But slimy is different than criminal, and not recognizing the differences is a serious problem, especially in terms of whether he should be allowed to work or not.

And I'm still waiting for an answer: did he take and then share pictures of any women without their permission?

#171

West Side Story revival?

Nope. The "should have known better" defense crap shows how antiquated your thinking is. <<edited by BWW staff>>. We have told you, many many times that these photos and videos were taken WITHOUT HER CONSENT OR KNOWLEDGE.

Considering we have given you five different articles STATING what he did, it's clear you don't want an answer, since it's already been presented. You just want to continue to say she asked for this.

Despicable.

Updated On: 7/10/19 at 06:41 PM

#172

West Side Story revival?

joevitus said: "If she willingly took or sent the photos, yes, she should have known better. That's just common sense. You take these kinds of pictures, or share them, you run the risk. As an adult, you have to own that.

If you voluntarily share something that personal and private with someone, of course, that person could share them with other people. That doesn't mean that they have the right to. While "revenge porn" is not yet illegal in New York apparently, it is in most states in the US, and even if it isn't illegal, it is wrong.

Doesn't make him any less slimy. But slimy is different than criminal, and not recognizing the differences is a serious problem, especially in terms of whether he should be allowed to work or not.

I don't think that anyone is arguing that illegal and slimy are the same thing, but what I think you are failing to recognize is that nearly everyone voicing concern in this thread and elsewhere think that there should be consequences for slimy behavior, whether it is illegal or not.

And I'm still waiting for an answer: did he take and then share pictures of any women without their permission?"

I am sure that you know how Google works. Why you feel the need for other people to find answers for you is odd.

#174

West Side Story revival?

It's still not clear here. Did Ramasar take the photos he had with permission or not? That makes a huge difference. The rest is just dirty talk, and like all dirty talk is offensive or not depending on the individual, but not threatening or criminal. If he photographed a woman's body without her consent, that's a crime. If he forced a woman to do something she didn't want, that's a crime. But did he?

Here is the complaint, with details: https://iapps.courts.state.ny.us/nyscef/ViewDocument?docIndex=Lis4cO2R91MS028v6xQ2zA==

It's not specified whether the pictures Ramasar sent were consensually taken, but considering the nature of the lawsuit, my common sense instinct tells me that if the pictures were demonstrably non-consensual it would have been mentioned in the complaint and used to further the plaintiff's argument.

You are not a good man.

Making categorical statements about strangers on the internet based on one random judgement is not a good look. Everyone is imperfect, including you.

We have told you, many many times that these photos and videos were taken WITHOUT HER CONSENT OR KNOWLEDGE.

Just to repeat the above, the photos from Ramasar shared were, as far as we know, consensual. Despite your all-caps proclamation, your information is incorrect.

#175

West Side Story revival?

https://gothamist.com/2018/09/05/nyc_ballet_lawsuit.php

"According to the lawsuit, Waterbury found out on May 15 of this year that Finlay "had been secretly recording and saving explicit photographs and videos of her while she was without clothing and/or while the two were engaged in sexual activities." She also discovered that they had been shared with many other people. The lawsuit maintains that Waterbury never consented to any of the photographs.

The lawsuit details instances of Finlay's texts. In September 2017, he allegedly sent a naked picture of her to colleagues, writing, "You have any pictures of girls you've f*cked?" which started a group text of them sharing explicit photos. Then, in May, he is accused of sharing another photo, and weeks later, Ramasar texted him, "I love you! Text me those photos/videos!! West Side Story revival?" Finlay allegedly complied, sending "one 'live' (i.e. short-second video burst)" of him and Waterbury engaged in a sexual act, then demanded that Ramasar send one in exchange. After they shared multiple images of various Ballet members, Finlay allegedly wrote, "Already seen that one. I know you have more."

The lawsuit also claims that Finlay asked another male NYC Ballet principal for explicit photographs of a female ballet member. He also allegedly texted with a donor who suggested they just "violate" female members—"I bet we could tie some of them up and abuse them... Like farm animals," to which Finlay allegedly responded, "Or like the sluts they are."

Finlay also allegedly talked about how he could sell recordings of Waterbury engaged in sexual acts."



Sharing someone's images without their permission--no matter if they were consensually obtained--is illegal in New York City, which passed such a law in 2017. (The state's law was finally passed in 2019.) Can anyone with half a brain actually believe someone would give permission for nude photographs to be distributed to her co-workers, in her workplace? Really? That's the defense Amansar's supporters are going with: "Maybe he had those women's permission to send her nude photographs to her co-workers!" Really?

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $60
Hot Show
Tickets From $71