Agree about Cymbeline.
Love, Lost is fine, but it's been around awhile now ...
(I recognize the OP is traveling in from out of town, but don't think it can fairly be called THE show of the Fall season -- at least not *this* Fall season!)
I also would give serious consideration to Elevator Repair Service's "The Select (The Sun Also Rises)" at New York Theater Workshop. A rock-solid stage adaptation, flawless performances, and some truly compelling staging.
"You, sir, are a moron." (PlayItAgain)