Personally, I wouldn't be surprised if Hercules took the St. James starting summer 2021. I suppose it would run for about as long as Newsies or Frozen did, generating solid buzz in the process.
And I know it's not certain as the sun rising in the east, but I see the Beauty and the Beast revival opening at the New Amsterdam fall 2022. Of course, Aladdin had been rather steady in ticket sales for about 6 years before the pandemic hit, but we'll never know what happens next until live theatre hopefully comes back next year. A big show like Beauty deserves a grand home, and I think the Lunt-Fontanne felt a little too intimate as it hosted most of its 13-year original Broadway run. Disney now owns the Amsterdam- it should be the obvious choice if Aladdin shows signs of mortality.
I hope Schumacher pulls a mouse out of his hat and creates this future for Disney on Broadway. Behold the new trifecta in Times Square before you know it: Lion King, Beauty and the Beast, and Hercules.
“I am furious, but I am sailing.”