In the recent Carrie reunion Buckley said that her performance in the into the woods workshop informed her performance for Carrie, and that she is kicking herself that she didn’t go forward with it*. While I am forever grateful that Bernadette* did it in the end, I definitely think Buckley would have had an amazing, amazing “Last Midnight” and “Stay with me” back then.
* interesting how Buckley makes it seem like she decided not to rather than was fired. I assume based on accounts here it was probably mutual though - Buckley wanted it to go in a certain direction and the creative team disagreed. So they parted ways. Cf. Bernadette who according to Arthur Laurents’ book does not act like a diva and will do what she is told to (to her own detriment in Gypsy according to Laurents).
Give me claws and a hunch, just away from this bunch.