But she gets RAVE reviews:
"I love her last "again!" I think she is just as good as Victoria Matlock. i also think she is the loudest Elphaba that there has been." jaszon27
"that last "again" riff is nothing short of orgasmic. i think i'm in love." zacxthexvacuum
"feee yeeeerrr ro ro roooo . <3 amazing riffs<3 i LOVE her" shannyloveyou
"her and lea michelle have the most beautiful voices." shannyloveyou
"ok, its official...Coleen is DEFINATLY my third favorite elphie now...(1.-Teal Wicks, 2.-Eden Espinosa) SHE IS A POWERHOUSE!!!?" Simbafan
Some people don't like her though:
"Needs some balls like Linda Edder, this girl doesn't have the range. A bit like Susan Boyle, no power/range whatsoever." godthisispainful
"Wow. This chick really can't act." Thatblkboy
"IDINA IS AMAZING. NO ARGUMENTS." Soon2beonbroadway
"not even half to linda eder's version...trying hard...tsk tsk!" xxSnAkEByTExx
And some people don't like the orchestra (strings):
"...orchestra (strings) is off at a few places too....wow" turnerrichard
Just some thoughts.
"These rabid fans...possess the acting talent to portray the hooker...Linda Eder..." -The New York Times
Updated On: 8/13/12 at 12:14 AM