I saw the show in London 7 years ago and I liked it. For me the biggest problem with the London production was Ian McShane's impersonating Jack Nicholson. The West End sets and costumes were superb. The three witches were each unique and the actress that played Felicia was a hoot. She had talent to spare.
The Signature production which I saw on Wednesday, June 13th had all 3 witches in flight and a great Darryl van Horne. What it lacked was the great opening number Eatswick Knows, a nice set (I'm sorry but nailing a picket fence upside down, add an oversize moon and puffy metal clouds didn't work for me), decent costumes (the women in the town were dressed in 1940's dresses, the men 1950's, The 3 witches were dressed in contemporary clothes except in the flying scene where they were dressed in medieval costumes ?!....as this intentional?)
The 3 witches were boring. I sort of liked the "tennis" witch. She was slightly sassy. The opening of each scene with Darryl van Horne and the Little Girl was creepy and inappropriate.
Marc Kudisch was stellar as he was in Assassins, The Apple Tree, Bells Are Ringing, etc.
The actress that played Felicia was one dimensional, too old (she had teenage daughter)and her voice was not distinct enough.
The song between the ingénues was painful and their costumes...she was wearing a pale dress with sequins and he was dressed like a farmer/nerd.
If you could take Marc Kudisch and put him the 2000 London production with a few slight changes to the show you would have a decent show. Not a Broadway caliber show. Just a decent, regional show.
timmmmmmmmmy