What a META- THEATRICAL thread.
It's interesting because this is a question that the stage show is actually ASKING its audience and Broadway.
Jeff: "And I'll make Broadway my eternal address!"
Hunter (blank paper): "Whoa, easy, motha*u*k*! Broadway? Let's start with Off or Off Off, and then you can think about the Great White Way."
Jeff: "But why can't I dream big?"
Hunter (blank paper): "Well, if it was a jukebox musical, a revival, or a recognizable commodity, I'd say 'Dream away, biotch!' But original? On Broadway? Baby, that is risky!!!"
Will people pay and come to see a "good product with talented people"? Do shows need to "hire some talent- free celebrity and lower the bar" in order to be a monetary success? Do they need to make other compromises?
Jeff: "Wow, an original musical!"
Hunter (blank paper): "That's right, cracka. Now there aren't many of us around, and it's a long journey, so let's get started!"
That's right... wrapped up in a very funny package is a very serious question about what kind of theatre and art the people want. And respond to. And will financially support.
I don't think that question will be answered in this thread with a few random theatre fans (out of many many people) arbitrarily sharing how much they will pay for a ticket.
I think that question will be answered starting July 5 at the Lyceum Theatre. So stay tuned.
Jeff: "When we set out to write this musical, we said we'd write a show that we want to see! We knew we'd never please everyone. Remember that day at Gristedes, you said to me: I'd rather be nine people's thing than a hundred people's ninth favorite thing. Nine people's favorite thing than a hundred people's ninth favorite thing."
Hunter: "Yeah you're right, Jeffy, let's not compromise. Let's keep making something we've never seen! A risk was taken with 'On The Town' and look what happened: Betty and Adolph burst onto the scene!"
Everyone: "A shout- out to Comden and Green!"
Every show that's ever been revolutionary started out by being risky and different- sounding.
Remember Oklahoma? "No gags, no gals, no chance!", they said.
Who says four chairs and a keyboard can't make a [financially successful] Broadway musical?!?!?!!?!?!?! WE'RE ENOUGH WITH ONLY THAT KEYBOARD! WE'RE OKAY WITH ONLY FOUR CHAIRS! WE'LL BE FINE WITH ONLY FOUR CHAIRS! WE'LL ROCK HARD WITH ONLY FOUR CHAIRS!
Who's with me?
[title of show] on Broadway. it's time. believe.