I agree, and I certainly understand why they changed the songs that way, although I hate it. "What's wrong with making mealtime a joyous occasion?" END. It's so Peanutsy that way. I much prefer the revised book, though. And the voices on the new CD are great, and it's them, combined with the 2.5 new songs that keep me listening to that one more often, and gumblingly skipping past the last ten seconds of almost every song. Even the ones that they couldn't do that to like "The Doctor is In" and "The Kite Song" have a little BOMP! at the end. Ecch.
I agree, the "buttons" on the end of every. single. song get pretty ridiculous. I directed a production of this and we were under a time constraint, so I took out the buttons of probably half the songs so that they wouldn't get a big appluase and we could keep the show moving. I actually liked the pace of the show much better that way than the way I've seen it done in other productions.
I played Schroeder in my school's production of You're A Good Man, Charlie Brown. We included Beethoven Day in the production and I'm a white guy.
Butters, go buy World of Warcraft, install it on your computer, and join the online sensation before we all murder you.
--Cartman: South Park
ATTENTION FANS: I will be played by James Barbour in the upcoming musical, "BroadwayWorld: The Musical."
I had a great time. Saw it twice, actually, and I'm an out-of-towner, so for me to see something twice with my limited time in the city says something.
On the other hand, I have since done two productions of it and would argue in retrospect that some of the choices limited the charm of a very charming piece.
Tams-Witmark EXPLICITLY FORBIDS adding the new songs if you are doing the "old" version. They make both versions available, and they make a strong point that the new version is not just the old version with two new songs added - it is a different show. You can't mix and match.