Saw it in Chicago the first night here. The cast was alright, that show just isn't very good.
I saw the OBC, too and I can tell you this: Roger Bart hates his life, to a fellow actor he is obviously very bored on that stage for most scenes...But somehow still pulls out a pretty good performance, and he made me laugh the most (but that could be because I find him hilarious, I have a bias). Whoever plays Inga did just as good as Sutton MINUS the vocals which were unimpressive (and p.s. I didn't think that highly of Sutton when I saw her, I thought she gave about 20% but even 20% from Sutton is pretty good). The woman playing Elizabeth (sorry Playbill isn't near) did her best to sound (speaking wise) exactly like Megan Mullay and once again didn't have the pipes to impress at all. But her acting was quite enjoyable. Shuler Hensley was great, but sadly isn't given that much to do. But Puttin' on the Ritz is by far the most entertaining part of the show. Igor also gave a very good, strong performance and made me laugh a few times.Frau Blucher (cue horses) was also well cast. The thing is none of these roles really have anything THAT spectacular to do. This is a show in my opinion for those audiences that have never heard of Sondheim and would pick going to the dentist over theatre most of the time.
p.s. During Ritz when the 4 leads start a simple time step, about half my audience (in CHICAGO no less, I thought we were smarter) tried to break into applause. for a SIMPLE TIME STEP.
JMO...that was longer than I intend it to be.
and all that I could do because of you was talk of love...