If you're a fan of the other Addams properties the musical is nothing like those. One would think they had never even heard of the Addams Family before writing it considering how they completely threw out the crucial aspect of them not knowing that they're creepy and kooky. They're much too self-aware.
That being said, I don't hate the score but I find the plot pretty dreary and a lot less funny than it could have and should have been (even in the revised version).
Keeping BroadwayWorld Illustrated