My personal opinion (and some of these aren't NEW NEW)--
1. Fun Home
2. Allegiance (Don't hate me because I put this before Hamilton--I just loved it, despite the negative opinions on this board)
3. Hamilton
4. Hand to God
5. King and I
My "meh" list includes
1. Something Rotten
2. Finding Neverland
3. Curious Incident (too much screaming and long 2nd act, I know I am in the minority)
4. American in Paris (great dancing, strange plot)