I can't remember the last time I felt like this after a show.
I just felt like I'd seen such greatness on the stage at the Booth tonight. And a story that really impacted me. If you'll recall, I liked the show at 2ST but had my reservations. I thought the second act dragged and there were moments of contrivance in the score. Not anymore.
The score is FANTASTIC. This is the rightful winner of the Best Score Tony. I've heard 9 TO 5's and like it, and I loved BILLY's but this score is just so brilliant. When it needs to rock out, it does. When it needs to be quiet and intimate (which is a lot of the time...if people go in thinking this is going to be like a rock concert, they will be letdown) it is...and both work wonderfully. The lyrics are gorgeous and so perfect. The new additions to the score are VERY welcome and the omissions of certain songs from 2ST were clearly in the show's best interest.
The book is wonderful as well. Clearly the writers did a lot more research about the illnesses they show covers. The book is great. Not as great as the score, but still. The characters are all clearly defined and the story is told at a suitable pace.
The performances. Sheesh. What a quintet of performers. Louis Hobson is strong (a definite improvement over Somers), Jennifer Damiano has done wonders with a complicated role, Adam Chanler Berat is adorable and very endearing, Aaron Tveit brought the house down with I'M ALIVE (still a bit too jumpy for me...but what a voice), and while he's not as good as D'Arcy James, J. Robert Spencer really impressed me.
But the show is Alice Ripley's. This just might be the best performance onstage since Ebersole in GREY GARDENS. I'm not going to harp on it, but what this woman does with Diana is simply mind-boggling. That Tony is hers. What a performance. Just unbelievably good.
Michael Greif's direction is much better than it was at 2ST. He seems a lot more comfortable with the tiered set. In fact, this may be his best directorial work yet. Loved the sets, loved the lights, the band sounded kick-ass.
There are flaws. I thought the first act was great but a bit uneven (not sure who to blame here) and the second act COULD benefit from a little trimming but not very much. That second act just tore my heart out.
I hope this show finds an audience. But interestingly enough, I think what will kill it is that second act. It's too dark, too intimate, too complicated, and not showy enough for the average Jane and Joe to get it or appreciate it. God, do I hope I'm wrong though. I just feel like during this recession, there's no way this can be a hit. But I hope I'm wrong.
It won't win the Tony for Best Musical; but it deserves it. And the nay-sayers, give it a chance. It's much better than SPRING AWAKENING (which I'll admit after my years of calling it a masterpiece, has flaws) and RENT. It's deeper, it's better-written, and it features a lead performance that will go down in musical theater history.
In a word, this show is thrilling. It gives me hope for the original American musical.
**** out of ****
Updated On: 3/28/09 at 12:27 AM