fashionguru, I have a copy of the published libretto of NO STRINGS, but have no way to scan it for you.
Trust me, you aren't missing a thing. I find it so dull as to be nearly unreadable. No wonder they put the musicians on stage! They needed to use it for something!
The gimmick of the show (in addition to the lack of strings) is that the interracial nature of the relationship between the leads is never mentioned. So what to talk about instead? Apparently, nobody figured that out.
That being said, I rather like the album. Richard Kiley and Diahann Carroll were wonderful singers.
jv92, I never thought about the Sondheim-Lapine fusion in that light. That is incredibly beautiful and filled with serendipity at its finest. It reminds me of the plot of "Once," only with less romantic tension. I hope such good fortune will come my way!
Rodgers wrote both the music and lyrics for "I Have Confidence" for the film version of The Sound Of Music after Hammerstein died. It was (of course) an excellent creation, but not quite of the same quality as the rest of the score. I found that the entire score of his later "Do I Hear A Waltz" to be of equal quality to "I Have Confidence" and which I very much enjoyed, but not quite on a par with his great works. One of the big problems with that musical is the book was incredibly dull and Sondheim later complained that he was dissatisfied with his own lyrics for it for that reason. But it was still, in my opinion, an excellent Rodger's score and likely his last noteworthy one.
The only Letter to the Editor of a newspaper I ever wrote was on the occasion of Rodger's death. He died on December 30, 1979 and his death, coming right before New Year's Eve, seemed to me to draw very little of the attention that it deserved.
Then about two days later I read a column on Rodgers by Ellen Goodman, the female columnist for the Boston Globe who was syndicated to Long Island Newsday. To me, that column completely damned him with faint praise and revealed how shallow she was.
Looking back at it now, it doesn't seem so awful, although I must remind myself that she didn't write the headline and that the column doesn't really support the headline. I probably went near ballistic over the unfavorable comparison to John Lennon. The two are not comparable. Lennon was a poet who put his singular lyrics into a lot of fair to forgettable melodies and some very memorable non-melodic vehicles such as "Strawberry Fields" and "The Walrus." I don't think that he was interested in melodies much and found good old rock and roll to be plenty enough. Two of my favorite Lennon songs are his rocking cover of Chuck Berry's "Rock and Roll Music" and the later "Ballad of John and Yoko."
But consider the number of different vocalists who have performed and/or recorded different Rodgers' songs. Thousands or tens of thousands. Lennon's songs are listened to lots but covered rarely.
And this: "Some Enchanted Evening" will never go into the annals of great classics. "The King and I" is not "Aida." Rodgers was a workaday artist and he knew it.
Read. Discuss.
Thousands of artists will be singing and recording "Some Enchanted Evening" a hundred years from now. "Bali Ha'i" is an amazing and complex work. Aside from the small number of opera lovers, who knows anything about Aida? An aria or two.
I think the fundamental flaw in the column is the thesis that Rodgers was not a great artist, as evidenced by the fact that composing was a lot of hard work for Rodgers, with the implication that great artists don't crack a sweat. In most cases, very untrue.
My letter was not, of course, published. Just as well.
thank you posters for turning me on to Pipe Dreams Encores 2012 recording...
just listened all the way through (2x)....Laura Osnes, Will Chase, Leslie Uggams and some fantastic orchestrations make for a really lively and thoroughly entertaining score with very memorable standouts songs and performances...WOW!
My favorite songs include:
Everybodys got a home but me
Sweet Thursday
The Man I used to be
All at Once you love her
Will You Marry Me
The Next time it happens
Are ALL FIRST RATE R&H songs at a level with some of their very best
I prefer the OBCR of PIPE DREAM in many ways, although nearly all of the songs are heard in edited form, but the Encores production was a gem I will always be grateful to have seen. My only complaint about the recording is that the gorgeous Spanish intro to "All At Once You Love Her" was not included.
The OBCR is heavily edited. The Spanish intro to All At Once You Love Her and the additional verses to many other songs, particularly Suzy Is A Good Thing, came as wonderful surprises when I heard them sung at Encores. The 1955 cast has a more operatic/legit sound than any cast you will hear today, including the Encores cast of Pipe Dream.
I am going to link some of the original cast's versions.
Laura is one of contemporary Broadway's greatest singing actresses and sounded beautiful live. Her voice is lighter and airier than Judy Tyler's, the original Suzy, but it's a matter of opinion which one you prefer. I think Judy's huskier sound worked better for a character who had been around the block, so to speak, but as I said Laura sang beautifully and they are both wonderful.
By the way, broadwaysfguy, the original cast did a few numbers on the Ed Sullivan show during the run of the show on Broadway. You might be able to see them in action if you search around for it. The episode is available on DVD and also features the cast of I Love Lucy.
I heard Julie tell that story. She auditioned for Richard Rodgers (Don't know what role) and afterwards he went up to her and took her aside and asked her if she had auditioned for any other roles. She said yes, she had auditioned for the role of Eliza in My Fair Lady. Rodgers told her that if she was offered the role of Eliza then she should take it, otherwise he thought that he would be able to use her.
Recently I found a recent interview with Barbara Cook concerning her performances in Rodgers and Hammerstein shows. She had played most of the major roles, but had not initiated any. She spoke of Rodgers with respect and admiration. She might have been holding back, but, based on the rest of the interview, it doesn't seem like she holds back very much.
Laura Osnes was perfectly cast as the Princess in Cinderella. She has been the Princess of Broadway for the last seven or so years. Young and pretty, with a sweet soprano, and always radiating warmth and good cheer. I missed her in South Pacific when she twice took over for Kelli O'Hara. Succeeding in that role must have been very good for her confidence, if it needed any boosting.
I saw her in Anything Goes, where her duet with Colin Donnell of Cole Porter's "It's Delovely" was a highlight second only to the tap extravaganza that ended the first act. On Youtube the two of them sing the duet in a couple of different venues. I also saw her in the October, 2014 City Center gala singing "It Might As Well Be Spring" and "The Lady is a Tramp." Also at City Center she was in the extended Encores theatricalization of the 1950s MGM musical The Band Wagon, which had starred Fred Astaire and Cyd Charisse with screenplay by Comden and Green. It introduced "That's Entertainment" and re-introduced from an old Broadway revue "Dancing in the Dark."
Here is Laura with Brian Stokes Mitchell and Tony Sheldon doing the well-known comic "Triplets" number from The Band Wagon"
It was thought that this two week Encores presentation was looking for a transfer to Broadway. If so, although a lot of fun, it didn't get the notices for Broadway. I was surprised when Laura was cast as Julie in Carousel because I just couldn't imagine her being as tragic as Julie had to be.
"How Can Love Survive" from THE SOUND OF MUSIC and "Come Home" from ALLEGRO are my two favorites. I believe that Rodgers continued to write beautiful melodies after Hammerstein passed. Listen to "Elizabeth" from REX and "You Could Not Please Me More" from I REMEMBER MAMA and hear the evidence.
My favorite is "Boys and Girls Like You and Me"-- cut from OKLAHOMA. I agree with others who like "So Far" a great deal, and with the fans of "You Are Beautiful." I would also add "When the Children Aree Asleep" from CAROUSEL. I can't believe some of the songs some of us are calling "lesser known," though. "It Might as Well Be Spring"? Seriously?
A great many of the posters are younger and/or havent had broad exposure to Rodgers & Hammerstein so I see these threads as educational and understand that "Lesser known" means something different to different people based on how much of a classic musical fan they may be....