I liked Young Sheldon quite a bit too... in fact, the only thing about the show that I didn't like was that it's "Young Sheldon." I watch Big Bang Theory casually when it's on, and I remember the earlier years of the show fairly well, and that's the show's biggest problem.
Single-camera dramedies, especially ones trying for a relatively subtle tone like this one seems to, thrive in growth and change, even just small amounts of continuity. And anyone who remembers the beginning of the Big Bang Theory knows, Sheldon Cooper begins (and remains for a while) as a lonely, awkward, completely socially maladjusted outcast whose intelligence and repeatedly-implied neurodiversity do not prevent him from being a pompous ass.
I want to believe, watching a show like this, that there's hope for the kid and his family. To go in knowing that Sheldon only gets worse, more divorced from the people around him and from humanity at large, renders the whole show as a sad joke on an autistic savant. The world doesn't learn to embrace him, he doesn't learn how to interact on the world's level; he just embraces a limited palette of what he can be and do, and shuts off the rest. And that's a heavy burden for this show to carry from episode one. If this show were called, say, "Smartypants," and narrated by Parsons as a tongue-in-cheek allusion to his most famous role, I'd be all in.
Updated On: 10/1/17 at 05:50 PM