Luscious, I think you got that right! I thought the same, especially when Simon stated that for once, he didn't care who would win it. I think he was trying to deflect having to say he wanted Cook to win, after having praised Archuletta, so much,the night before. I also think it was a "psych" move.
Also, though, I think the "father" thing with Archuletta got people a bit put out...I think some people actually went for the "underdog" here, on purpose.
Well, I think Cook is "top dog", for me! And it was the happiest I have been about an AI winner, so far!!! Finally, America is starting to recognize true musical talent, and going past the "tweenies" favorites