Broadway Legend Joined: 7/8/05
That arrangement/song choice for Kat was not right at all!!
I think that screwed her over. At least Simon realized she didn't pick the song. As soon as I heard what it was I thought it was the wrong choice. Oy, Clive!
I still find Taylor incredibly off-putting, but he did a decent job there.
Aww, I like Taylor. I hope it's a Taylor/Elliot final.
(Ok, 4 "Soul Patrols" was plenty...ENOUGH!)
Children, children!
What the hell is going on here?!?!
I guess I just don't care anymore.
Great performance by Elliott. Paula picked the perfect song for him.
How long before the judges/Seacrest just full-on FREAK.OUT?!?!?
I see a major spat in the near future. Good times.
Katharine is boring me to tears here. I'm really curious to hear what the Three Stooges have to say.
Yeah, I don't get Katherine. I thought she finished the song well, but the start was kind of sketchy, imho. I just don't like her...a did I catch a little wink to Simon? Hmmm...
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/8/05
I thought she sounded great too.
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/10/05
Kat sounded great! I'm not a fan, but she sounded great. Taylor was ok.
Yeah, didn't do it for me. Eh...I thought he sounded fine, but it was kind of icky to watch.
Taylor sounded like he was constipated. Completely undeserving of the tonguebath from the judges.
I enjoy him much more when I just listen and don't watch him.
Videos