Whodunnit?- Page 3
Whodunnit?
#50Whodunnit?
Posted: 7/15/13 at 2:31pm
I've watched some really bad reality shows in the past (Cold Turkey, anyone?) but this is definitely one of the worst. I agree with Whizzer that the scripted nature of everything is very distracting from the point. Like everything is placed there in order for the contestants to see it. "Is this dried blood?" Who knows because it's not real blood so we can't tell if it's fake dried blood. And everyone acting so shocked at hearing the The Killer (who Giles has in his iPhone as such) when it was all stuff that I'm sure the producers told them to say.
I'll keep watching and hate myself for doing so. While I think Geno is the killer it seems like they'd want it to be a woman because that would probably be less expected. Is the person who is the killer really an actor because it seems rude for them to be a real contestant that has no shot at winning.
#52Whodunnit?
Posted: 7/15/13 at 2:40pm
Every week it just makes me miss THE MOLE more and more.
Stop it! You'll make me cry. I miss that show so much.
This show is craptastic. The way these people behave as if it's all real reminds me of those crazy Ren Fest families you see time and again on Wife Swap. I keep reminding myself it's probably fun for them, but boy is it uneasy to watch.
Just before the end of episode three, Ronnie said and did something that maybe he's the killer. But the campy melodramatics of all the players make it difficult to decipher anything that may seem abnormal. I just wonder what all these people are doing while each setup is staged. I can't imagine how long it must take to set up all the scenes for each murder and clue hunt.
#53Whodunnit?
Posted: 7/15/13 at 2:41pmOh and did I miss something or did no one figure out the riddle that gives them a clue? It seems like they all just did their own thing and talked about the cyanide.
#54Whodunnit?
Posted: 7/15/13 at 2:45pm^ I wouldn't know because Goddamn Eyewitness News broke in at that point with 'breaking news.' It was about the protest going on in Times Square regarding the Zimmerman verdict. When NJ Burkett reported that 'Everyone is well-behaved' and there's nothing actually happening worth a 'breaking news report,' I got so mad that I wanted to release a mountain lion on someone.
#55Whodunnit?
Posted: 7/15/13 at 3:14pm
I got upset at the "breaking news" update too. Unless there is actually something urgent to tell us they should wait the 20 more minutes it would take to get to the nightly news.
Clyde, The killer is acting more than the other contestants. He or she was told before the game started that he or she was the killer. They were not told anything else though- definitely not how any of the crimes would be committed or how to solve the riddles. This way everyone is on an equal playing field and the killer can't accidentally give themselves away by knowing too much. They are competing honestly in the challenges, but as far as I know not eligible for the money.
#56Whodunnit?
Posted: 7/16/13 at 10:55amMy favorite moment so far was when Karen Walker figured out the cyanide bit.
#57Whodunnit?
Posted: 7/16/13 at 3:55pmSpeaking of horrible shows like this, has anyone see Siberia? I tried the first episode but only got halfway through but I turned it off. Gotta have some limits.
#58Whodunnit?
Posted: 7/16/13 at 5:22pmI have a couple of friends begging me to watch Siberia so they can discuss it, so I'm starting that series tomorrow.
#59Whodunnit?
Posted: 7/22/13 at 10:31am
Oh Em Gee....an double murder at the manor but why why why did they pick goddess Dana and sassy Sasha at the same time. Where's the drama going to come from now.
Great episode though.
#60Whodunnit?
Posted: 7/22/13 at 11:13am
Last night's episode was the most "serious" so far. The case was actually interesting a little more difficult to solve than some of the others.
Next week looks like a riot though! They have been dipped in wax?! And there are wax replicas of the remaining contestants that they have to rip open to find clues?! Yes please!
#61Whodunnit?
Posted: 7/22/13 at 11:34am
How could they not keep Dana until the very end. She is the definition of good TV!!! Do I need to watch the Kam and Lindsey show for the rest of the time? Wretched.
But the wax...oh, the wax. How brilliant.
StockardFan
Broadway Legend Joined: 6/19/08
#63Whodunnit?
Posted: 7/22/13 at 1:16pmred touches black youre ok Jack red touches yellow your a dead fellow
#64Whodunnit?
Posted: 7/22/13 at 4:20pm
RED TOUCHES BLACK YOU'RE OK, JACK! R.I.P. Dana and Sasha. You will both be missed.
This was definitely the best episode so far. Although Giles was like insane talking about going to take a tinkle in the woods. I wonder how long it took them to find the weapon in that shed. It seemed like they all went in like 20 times.
Did anyone else think the shot of Kam reading Brian Greene's The Hidden Reality was a little weird? Possibly a clue to the killer.
#65Whodunnit?
Posted: 7/23/13 at 12:29pmI don't know if I can continue to watch now that Karen Walker's dead. That really pisses me off.
#66Whodunnit?
Posted: 7/23/13 at 5:22pm
"Way too elegant for that." -- RIP Dana, my queen. I'm torn between being sad Sasha is gone and happy, because she was a crazy bitch, but oh so fun to watch. Their 'death' discovery was creepy as hell, though.
I'm SOOO tired of Lindsey, like can she just be killed soon? I'm torn between the killer being Cris, Kam, or Ronnie.
StockardFan
Broadway Legend Joined: 6/19/08
#68Whodunnit?
Posted: 7/28/13 at 11:20pm
This has been the best episode yet. I find it kind of annoying that they've started doing interesting murders that take some effort to figure out this late in the season.
I would have hated to be Dana and Sasha during those morgue examinations. Having people putting tweezers up your nose would make it impossible not to laugh.
Giles continues to be a madman! My guess for Geno being the killer was wrong. I'm going to go with Melina.
#69Whodunnit?
Posted: 7/28/13 at 11:25pm
Dana was totally cracking a smile when she was frozen by the piano tonight! I think she had the hardest time acting out her death.
I agree that it was a good crime to figure out. The early deaths were so basic compared to these last two.
I will be shocked if the killer isn't a woman.
#70Whodunnit?
Posted: 7/29/13 at 11:18am
What an awesome creepy episode. I <3 this show so much.
Dana wheeling Sasha's stiff cold body around was so sad. hehehe
Did anyone else think Giles was a goner when doing limbo?
RIP Geno
I beginning to think it's Melina, she's never been scared.
#71Whodunnit?
Posted: 7/29/13 at 12:08pmDana was HILARIOUS in the murder reenactment. I just pray she gets a role in Sharknado II: Bite the Big Apple.
#72Whodunnit?
Posted: 8/5/13 at 9:27am
I loved Geno dancing in his reenactment scene. The two women he was dancing with (backs to the camera) were clearly body doubles for Cris and a straight-haired Melina!
Poor Ronnie and that stupid theory about the monkey. I couldn't believe he actually went with that. There was NO evidence to support that craziness! I was laughing when he told the rest of them what he said at the dinner table.
I was fairly certain that Cris has been the killer for a while, but now I might change horses at the last minute and go with Melina.
#73Whodunnit?
Posted: 8/12/13 at 10:37am
What is even going on with this show now?!?!
It's pretty hilarious to think that liquid nitrogen being pumped into the pool would freeze the teacup next to it. The killer also needs to stop with the poisoning masked by some really elaborate ruse.
Is Melina really dead? Who kidnapped Giles and put all those machine guns attached to fishing lines around him? How is the killer able to raise the dead? These questions and many more answered next week on the SERIES finale (who are we kidding) of Whodunnit!
#74Whodunnit?
Posted: 8/12/13 at 10:48am
Clyde no! I was just telling my friend that this is the SEASON and not SERIES finale! I want to be a contestant on Season 2, even if I have to fund it myself.
I don't know if Melina is really dead. I thought for sure she was the killer this entire episode. She figured out WAY too much stuff not to be aided by the producers in some way.
She just magically figured out that Ronnie was writing a letter in the library? That we was probably drinking something poolside? Considering how dumb she's been the rest of the season I can't believe she suddenly knew all she did after only going to the morgue.
It was a weak episode though, especially since the last few have been much better.
If one of them is the killer when did they have time to tie up poor Giles!
Videos