OffOnBwayHi said: "meh. ugh. Like, why not just transfer direct to Broadway?! it already proved itself — in NYC, off-Broadway. Why is a transfer seeminglyso hard for this show...and others like it? You know what I mean...
Cause, if we're being honest, if 'Unknown Soilders' in some surprising way became a big hit (which it won't), a transfer would be undeniable.
Why is 'Sing Street' on Broadway this season and 'Strange Loop' is not...or will never be? Answers please."
I think you're reading too much into these things. There are TONS of factors that go into a Broadway transfer. And there is really no point in trying to make any claims by comparing it to other shows. Sing Street is coming to Broadway right away because all of their stars aligned to do so. And Strange Loop isn't yet, which could be for any number of reasons.
Theatre availability is a big one: do we know that the Barrymore hasn't already been booked by something? And maybe they don't feel that's the right theatre for them anyway.
Also, just because A Strange Loop proved itself in a small Off-Broadway house for a limited run, doesn't mean it will have the same viability in a larger, commercial run. Maybe investors didn't have enough confidence to move it right away, so the want to do another run to make changes or build buzz.
Plus, there are plenty of shows that did well Off-Broadway that still went on to have out-of-town, or additional Pre-Broadway runs before finally transferring. Great Comet, Hadestown, Six, and Girl From the North Country are all recent examples of this.
And even if a transfer doesn't pan out, that's not the end of the world. Many wonderful shows don't go to Broadway. Fans of the show should be glad it had such a successful run Off-Broadway, received a cast album, and is now getting another life. And if it ends up going to Broadway, all the better!
Let's all just take a deep breath!
Updated On: 3/9/20 at 12:57 PM