Based on the video of Ms Altomare performing I've seen, she does a really great job of singing a beloved song. I'm not, however, getting the sense of that being a Tony-winning performance. I know belting the first act closer seems to be a way to get nominated (Sutton Foster in Little Women, for instance), and I haven't seen the rest of her undoubtedly appealing performance, but... it's not much beyond someone standing at the mike and singing it, in some ways. I guess I would prefer more dynamic staging or something; she does a good job vocally of conveying the change from trepidation to excitement, but there's only so much you can do with a park-and-bark belty solo.
Then again, I haven't seen - and will never see - any of the other potential nominees, so what do I know?
disneybroadwayfan22 said: "So, Christy Altomare's "Journey to the Past" is going viral on Facebook. Telling from the comments and the hits, I'm starting to wonder if Christy can possibly -and hopefully- pull a giant upset at the Tonys for Best Leading Actress next year? "
Since when has the reaction to a video ever been an indication of whether someone will be nominated, let alone win, a Tony?
You should be holding off your wondering until March, when we know exactly who she'll be up against. If War Paint and Sweet Charity both transfer this season, then she will be very fortunate if she is nominated.
"...everyone finally shut up, and the audience could enjoy the beginning of the Anatevka Pogram in peace."
Kad said: "disneybroadwayfan22 said: "Since when has the reaction to a video ever been an indication of whether someone will be nominated, let alone win, a Tony?"
It could attract buzz (like Hamilton) and the commenters could be a foreshadowing of the critics' thoughts
Hamilton earned its buzz through word of mouth from people who saw the show- and the reporting of who saw the show, as well as critical accolades not once but twice.
Reaction of people on Facebook to one song is only indicative that they like that one song.
It is also the reaction of many people who probably are already predisposed to like it. It's not a poll.
We already have an idea of how critics will react to the show... because critics have already reacted to it.
"...everyone finally shut up, and the audience could enjoy the beginning of the Anatevka Pogram in peace."