Trisky, I could not agree with you more on your reaction to the LA cast lyric changes, I do think that the LA version has some really great spoken words that seemed to have been cut from NY, that really help with some of the character development ITA! Firstly Claire is hysterical in Ephiphany - "Peter is turning cartwheels on the lawn". Lyric wise, really "he's on his way to supergay" is hysterical. What really strikes me is Portrait of a Girl and what a huge difference that little exchange with Ivy trying to show Sr. Chantelle the sketches she drew and being rejected makes for the character and the song. Whereas in NY, it just seems kind of la-di-da she's singing about her costume, in L.A. the song seems to have more weight.
I am just hoping that when it comes back in Oct. there are not more lines that i have to let go of I'm already dreading this since I'm bad with change, but I'm also strangely looking forward to seeing what they think needed more work and whether it's in tune with some of the stuff we've discussed on this thread.
Oh stop it! :P And I guess the problem I have with it is that I never got a sense that Nadia was all that disappointed not to win Juliet. A bummer, yes but it just didn't seem like a big deal. Ah, see, I did get the sense that she was really disappointed because I think it was just another moment of her not being pretty/perfect enough, in her mind. She also sarcastically refers to "all Juliets" in A Quiet Night at Home, which made me think it was still on her mind.
And when I listened to Michael sing "Role of a Lifetime" for the first time, I was so moved. The power of the vocals, the intesity, everything about it was amazing. I just don't know if I would have felt that with this version or this cast. I know, it's hard to imagine. And also this seemed to be just a reading, not the actual staged version, so who knows what differences there were between that and the actors actually having a set, costumes, etc. But definitely the cast makes a huge difference, especially Michael. I can't get past the warble on L.A. Peter and the fact that he doesn't look at all like an adorkable school boy, but the school hottie which really throws the dynamic of Peter/Jason off a bit.
Thanks for the love guys! Totally undeserved, but sweet nonetheless. Just give me a while to piss you off. Heh.
"Too young to hold on and too old to just break free and run" - Jeff Buckley
Updated On: 8/29/04 at 01:18 PM