I've been going for 7 years now, and I agree that this was the weakest year. And I'm sorry, things are getting out of hand what with lines and such. I did get some good finds, though:
Hello, Dolly! Metal Water Bottle (I LOVE this- I needed a metal one for my new job, and this one is all red and sleek and just says HELLO, DOLLY! Broadway 2017)
Hello, Dolly! Program (they were selling slightly bent ones for $20 rather than $40 in theatre- it's already under some books to press it back)
Lion King Blanket (with a free ornament)
She Loves Me Tony Press Box (stuffed vanilla ice cream - so cute!)
Avenue Q Tickets from the leftover $20 Pik-a-Tik envelopes (excited!)
Hedwig and the Angry Inch metal ticket keychain
About 5 Playbills
One of the Phantom of the Opera signboards for my sister for Christmas
Not a ton of stuff, but I was really happy with the finds I did manage. I didn't even bother with the Dear Evan Hansen or Great Comet lines, since I knew anything they had would be rather pricey and that I probably wouldn't buy it anyway. I didn't buy a ton of stuff, but I am very, very happy with what I did get, so it was a good day!